AI Anime Art Service Tier List

Sanime
18 Dec 202212:46

TLDRThe video script offers a comprehensive review of various AI anime art generation services, categorizing them into tiers based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters and overall user experience. The reviewer shares personal experiences with each service, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses, and provides insights into the rapid advancements in AI art technology. The top-tier services, such as Novel AI, are praised for their consistency, speed, and quality of life features, while others are critiqued for their limitations and lack of control over the generation process.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 The speaker is an artist who explores with AI art generation but doesn't consider themselves a master draftsman.
  • 🌟 AI art, particularly generating anime characters, is seen as a perk of the AI Revolution.
  • 🚫 The speaker warns against harsh criticism and negative comments on art generated by AI.
  • 📋 The speaker has extensive experience with various AI anime art services and plans to review them.
  • 🔎 A tiered system is used to categorize the AI art services based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters.
  • 🏆 Tier A services are highly praised for their speed and quality, with Novel AI being the top choice for consistency and compatibility across devices.
  • 💻 Tier B services, like Pixai, offer powerful free options but are hindered by slower generation times and token systems.
  • 🌐 Tier C services are specialized in anime character generation and provide better results than lower tiers but with less versatility.
  • 🚧 Tier D services struggle to create anime characters effectively and are criticized for their speed and output quality.
  • 🔄 The speaker discusses the evolution of AI art services and the rapid improvements seen in recent years.
  • 💰 The cost and value of different services are compared, with some offering better price-to-quality ratios than others.
  • 📊 The importance of user interface and quality of life features in AI art services is emphasized, affecting the overall user experience.

Q & A

  • What is the main message the speaker wants to convey at the beginning of the transcript?

    -The speaker wants to emphasize that being an artist and using AI for art generation does not diminish their artistic skills. They also encourage people to respect different artistic journeys and discourage leaving negative comments.

  • What are the speaker's thoughts on AI-generated anime art?

    -The speaker finds AI-generated anime art fascinating and considers it one of the perks of the AI Revolution. However, they also note that there are limitations to the quality and speed of different AI art services.

  • How does the speaker categorize the AI art generation services they discuss?

    -The speaker categorizes the AI art generation services into tiers: D, C, B, and A, based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters, speed, and overall quality.

  • What are some of the services the speaker considers to be in the D tier?

    -The services in the D tier include Starry AI, Night Cafe Dream by Womble Ai, and Neural Love. These services are not great at creating anime girls and are also slow.

  • What are the main drawbacks of the D tier services according to the speaker?

    -The main drawbacks of the D tier services are their inability to create high-quality anime characters and their slow generation speed. Additionally, they run on a token system that the speaker does not find worth the investment.

  • How does the speaker describe the 'This Anime Does Not Exist' service?

    -The speaker describes 'This Anime Does Not Exist' as a service that uses a custom-trained model based on StyleGAN 2. While it can create decent anime characters, it has a lot of classic AI 'jank' and lacks specific control over the generated images.

  • What are the advantages of Waifu Labs V2 according to the speaker?

    -Waifu Labs V2 is praised for its specialized focus on creating anime characters, resulting in better quality compared to lower tiers. It also offers more control over the generation process through its use of 'latents' and is noted for its impressive speed.

  • What is the main issue the speaker has with Pixai, the service in the B tier?

    -The main issue with Pixai is the speed of image generation. Despite its high-quality output and good control over the images, the service can take minutes to generate an image, which prevents it from being a top-tier service.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the new section 'AI or I'?

    -The speaker is not fully versed in 'AI or I' as it is a new service. They find the free version to be of little use due to lack of control, and while the paid plans seem promising, the speaker is not a fan of the token system and finds it to be a worse deal compared to its competitors.

  • What factors contribute to Novel AI being considered the best service according to the speaker?

    -Novel AI is considered the best due to its consistency, compatibility with various devices, fast image generation, and quality of life features such as saved images and prompt storage in metadata.

  • What is the speaker's main concern about the cost of Novel AI?

    -The speaker is concerned about the cost of Novel AI, finding it expensive, especially for users who may want to generate a large number of images.

  • How does the speaker feel about the user interface of Pixai?

    -The speaker finds the user interface of Pixai to be annoying, with resolution and negative problem settings hidden behind a dropdown and a cumbersome process for saving tags between images.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Artistic Expression and AI Art Services Overview

The speaker begins by asserting their identity as an artist and addresses potential criticisms of AI art. They clarify that experimenting with AI art doesn't diminish their artistic abilities. The speaker appreciates the AI revolution's ability to generate anime characters and acknowledges the vast array of AI image generation services available. They express a desire to review every AI anime art service they've used, noting that some services are not as adept at creating anime characters as others. The speaker plans to group these services and discuss their reasons for ranking them low in detail, highlighting the impressive capabilities of Stable Diffusion's novel AI model introduced months prior.

05:01

📊 Tiered Ranking and Evaluation of AI Art Services

The speaker delves into the specifics of various AI art services, categorizing them into tiers based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters. They discuss the D-tier services, which are slow and not ideal for anime character generation, despite some positive aspects. The speaker then moves on to C-tier services, which are more specialized and yield better results. They provide a detailed critique of 'This Anime Does Not Exist' and 'Waifu Labs V2', discussing their features, drawbacks, and improvements. The speaker also touches on B-tier services, specifically 'Xai', and its strengths and weaknesses, including the challenges with its token system and generation speed. Lastly, they introduce a new section for a recently released AI service, expressing initial thoughts on its features and limitations.

10:01

🏆 The Pinnacle of AI Art Services: Novel AI and its Competitors

In the final paragraph, the speaker discusses the A-tier AI art services, which represent the best in the field. They highlight the advantages of using one's own computer for art generation, the limitations of hardware, and the potential of Novel AI. The speaker praises Novel AI for its consistency, compatibility across devices, and speedy image generation. They also appreciate the quality of life features of Novel AI, such as saved images and prompt storage in metadata. However, they note the high cost and the possibility that some may prefer alternative models. The speaker concludes by acknowledging the evolving nature of AI art and the potential for future advancements.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI art

AI art refers to the creation of visual art using artificial intelligence. In the context of the video, it involves the use of AI to generate anime-style images, which is the main focus of the artist's exploration. The artist discusses various AI art services and their effectiveness in creating anime characters, highlighting the advancements and limitations of each service.

💡Stable diffusion

Stable diffusion is a type of AI model that has been trained on a wide range of images to generate high-quality, stable outputs. In the video, the artist praises the stable diffusion model for its ability to create detailed and consistent anime characters, setting it apart from other models that may produce less coherent results.

💡Anime characters

Anime characters are the stylized depictions of humans, animals, or other beings originating from anime, a form of Japanese animation. The video's main theme revolves around the artist's journey to find the best AI services for generating anime characters, evaluating the quality and authenticity of the characters produced by different AI platforms.

💡Token system

A token system in the context of AI art generation services refers to a mechanism where users must purchase a certain number of tokens to generate images. The more tokens a user has, the more images they can create. The artist in the video critiques some of these systems, arguing that they are not always worth the investment due to the varying quality of the generated art.

💡Custom training

Custom training in AI refers to the process of fine-tuning a pre-existing AI model with specific data sets to improve its performance in a particular task. In the video, the artist appreciates the custom training that has been done for certain AI services, enabling them to generate anime characters more effectively.

💡Latents

In the context of AI image generation, latents refer to underlying features or characteristics of an image that can be manipulated to alter the final output. The artist in the video is positive about services like Waifu Labs that allow the modification of latents, providing more control over the generation process and enabling the creation of images closer to the user's desired outcome.

💡Speed of thought

The phrase 'speed of thought' is used to describe an extremely fast and responsive system or process, one that operates at a pace that seems almost instantaneous to the user. In the video, the artist values AI art services that can generate images at the 'speed of thought,' enhancing the user experience by reducing wait times.

💡Price and quality

Price and quality are critical factors that users consider when evaluating AI art services. The artist discusses the balance between the cost of using a service and the quality of the art it produces, noting that some services offer better value for money than others.

💡User interface (UI)

User interface, or UI, refers to the design and layout of a software application that allows users to interact with it. In the context of the video, the artist expresses frustration with certain UI elements of AI art services, such as hidden settings and the lack of saved tags between images, which can hinder the user experience.

💡Innovation

Innovation in this context refers to the introduction of new technologies, features, or methods that significantly improve the performance or functionality of AI art services. The artist emphasizes the rapid pace of innovation in the AI art industry and how it affects the capabilities and relevance of different services.

💡Quality of life features

Quality of life features are those that enhance user experience and make a service more convenient or enjoyable to use. In the video, the artist highlights certain features of Novel AI, such as saved image prompts and faster image generation, as quality of life improvements that make it a top choice for AI art generation.

Highlights

The speaker is an artist who explores various AI art generation services.

AI art, such as generating anime girls and boys, is a perk of the AI Revolution.

There are many AI image generation services, but not all are equally good at creating anime characters.

The speaker has been tracking AI art services for years.

Some AI art services are slow and not specialized in anime characters.

The novel AI's model of stable diffusion stands out among other models for creating anime characters.

The speaker categorizes AI art services into tiers based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters.

Services like Starry AI, NightCafe, Dream by Womble AI, and Neural Love are grouped together for their shortcomings.

The speaker praises the older module 'Anime does not exist' for its charm despite its limitations.

Waifu Labs V2 is highlighted for its specialized training for anime characters and user control.

The speed of Waifu Labs is commendable, offering near-instant generation.

Pixai is noted for its use of a modified version of Novel AI's stable diffusion and its token system.

The speaker introduces a new section, AI or horror, discussing a service that just came out.

The free version of the new AI service is criticized for its lack of control.

The paid plans of the new AI service are questioned for their value and token system.

Holara is mentioned as a service with potential but currently not favored by the speaker.

Novel AI is at the top due to its consistency, speed, and quality of life features.

The speaker concludes that Novel AI is the best option for those without high-end computers or a monthly budget for other services.