Are Programmers Obsolete? Will AI Replace Them?

Dave's Garage
14 Jan 202409:46

TLDRThe video script discusses the impact of AI on software engineering jobs, arguing that while some jobs may be automated, others will become more valuable. The speaker, a retired software engineer, emphasizes the importance of complex problem-solving, human intuition, and ethical decision-making in software development, which AI cannot replicate. The future of software engineering looks bright, with a shift towards working alongside AI to tackle challenging tasks and creating user-centric applications.

Takeaways

  • 🌟 Software engineering jobs are evolving, with some disappearing and others gaining more value due to advancements in AI.
  • 🔍 The speaker, Dave, believes that high-level programmers who work on complex tasks will continue to thrive, while those doing more routine tasks may face job displacement.
  • 💡 AI like Chat GPT is improving but still lacks the ability to handle complex debugging and synchronization issues that expert programmers deal with.
  • 🚚 The analogy of truck driving to software engineering suggests that while some jobs may become less human-dependent, new, more skilled roles will emerge.
  • 📈 AI is expected to create an explosion of jobs in its development, potentially leading to more software engineering positions than currently exist.
  • 🔧 The bulk of software engineering work involves debugging and validation, not just coding, which AI is less equipped to handle.
  • 🔄 The example of porting code from Windows 95 to NT illustrates the kind of complex, backward-compatible work that AI is unlikely to solve on its own.
  • 🤖 As AI's coding abilities improve, the role of software engineers will shift towards working alongside AI, focusing on areas requiring human creativity and problem-solving.
  • 🛠️ Human programmers will still be needed for complex problem-solving, understanding user needs, ethical decision-making, and customizing software for specific clients.
  • 🚀 The demand for skilled software engineers to build, update, and manage AI systems is likely to increase as AI technology evolves.

Q & A

  • What is the speaker's background in the software engineering field?

    -The speaker, Dave, is a retired software engineer who worked at Microsoft during the MS-DOS and Windows 95 era. He has been a professional software engineer for about 40 years, starting with programming in BASIC and Assembly Language, then moving on to C, C++, C, JavaScript, and Python.

  • What is Dave's perspective on the impact of AI like Chat GPT on software engineering jobs?

    -Dave believes that while some programming jobs will be replaced by AI, others will become more valuable. He argues that AI may take over routine tasks, but complex problem-solving, understanding human needs, and customization will still require human engineers.

  • How much time did Dave spend on coding compared to debugging and validating code?

    -Dave estimates that he spent about 20% of his time coding and the remaining 80% on debugging and validating code.

  • What was a significant project Dave worked on in 1994?

    -Dave worked on porting the Windows 95 shell over to Windows NT, which involved updating the codebase for Unicode compatibility and ensuring it worked with the NT kernel.

  • What challenges did Dave face while porting the Windows 95 shell to Windows NT?

    -One of the challenges was handling file shortcuts in a backward-compatible but forward-looking way, ensuring that shortcuts created on Windows 95 would work on Windows NT and vice versa without causing any system crashes.

  • How does Dave envision the future role of software engineers in relation to AI?

    -Dave sees software engineers focusing on complex, creative, and interpersonal aspects of software development that AI cannot replicate. Engineers will work in a feedback loop with AI, tweaking results and providing human insights and problem-solving where AI falls short.

  • What are some of the reasons why Dave believes software engineering jobs can still be secure?

    -Dave cites complex problem-solving, human insight and intuition, ethical decision-making, customization for specific client needs, and the demand for professionals to build and manage AI systems as reasons why software engineering jobs can remain secure.

  • How does Dave suggest software engineers maximize their chances of success in the face of AI advancements?

    -Dave advises software engineers to position themselves on the higher end of the competency curve, focusing on areas where AI is less likely to disrupt, and aiming to be indispensable in their roles.

  • What is the speaker's advice for software engineers working on mundane tasks that might be automated by AI?

    -Dave suggests that instead of writing entry-level code, software engineers might shift towards writing prompts and providing feedback that tunes AI in the production of software, effectively becoming a liaison between the customer and the AI.

  • How does Dave describe the potential future of software engineering in relation to AI?

    -Dave describes a future where AI takes over the 'grunt work' of coding, but human engineers will still be needed to handle complex problem-solving, ethical decision-making, and customization. He compares it to a new 'Gold Rush', where dedicated and innovative engineers will find new opportunities.

  • What additional resources does Dave offer for individuals on the autism spectrum or those who know someone with autism?

    -Dave offers a book on Aspergers and ASD, which he believes contains valuable information that he wishes he had known earlier. The book covers topics such as working with, managing, and various employment issues related to autism.

Outlines

00:00

🌟 The Future of Software Engineering

This paragraph discusses the impact of AI on software engineering jobs. The speaker, Dave, a retired software engineer, argues that while some programming jobs may be automated by AI, others will become more valuable. He emphasizes the importance of overall competence and problem-solving skills over specific languages or technologies. Dave suggests that the most skilled programmers, who work on complex issues like debugging and system integration, will continue to be in demand. He also mentions that the nature of software engineering jobs will evolve, with a potential increase in roles that involve working with AI systems.

05:02

🤖 AI's Role in Software Development

In this paragraph, Dave explores the future trajectory of AI in software development. He posits that AI will continue to improve and may eventually produce complete solutions and applications. However, he highlights the importance of human software engineers in addressing complex problems, understanding user needs, and making ethical decisions. Dave also discusses the potential for AI to assist in code generation, while humans will focus on more intricate tasks. He concludes by encouraging software engineers to aim for high competency to remain valuable in the evolving landscape of software development.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Software Engineering

Software engineering refers to the application of engineering principles to the design, development, testing, and maintenance of software. In the video, the speaker discusses the evolution of software engineering and how certain aspects of the job may be automated by AI, while others will become more valuable, emphasizing the importance of complex problem-solving and human-centric design skills.

💡AI and Programming

AI and programming refers to the use of artificial intelligence to automate the process of writing and maintaining code. In the context of the video, the speaker argues that while AI like Chat GPT may take over some routine programming tasks, it will not replace the need for skilled software engineers who can tackle complex issues and provide creative solutions.

💡Complex Problem Solving

Complex problem solving involves the ability to tackle challenging, unstructured issues that require deep understanding, creativity, and innovation. In the video, it is suggested that despite AI's capabilities in automating certain tasks, complex problem solving in software engineering is a human skill that AI has yet to master, making it a crucial aspect of the software engineer's role.

💡Debugging

Debugging is the process of finding and fixing errors or bugs in software code. It is a critical part of software development that often requires a deep understanding of the codebase and the ability to troubleshoot issues effectively. In the video, the speaker emphasizes that while AI may assist in coding, the skill of debugging, especially for complex and synchronization issues, will remain a valuable human expertise.

💡Human-Centric Design

Human-centric design is an approach to software development that prioritizes understanding and meeting the needs of the end-users. It involves considering human behaviors, preferences, and ethical considerations in the design process. The video highlights that AI lacks the innate human ability to intuitively grasp these aspects, making it essential for software engineers to bring their insights and intuition to create user-friendly applications.

💡Customization and Personalization

Customization and personalization refer to the process of tailoring software to meet specific client needs or contexts. This often requires a deep understanding of the client's requirements and the ability to adapt the software accordingly. In the video, the speaker suggests that AI, in its current state, is not adept at fully grasping and adapting to varied and nuanced requirements, which underscores the ongoing need for skilled software engineers.

💡Ethical and Decision-Making Considerations

Ethical and decision-making considerations involve making choices that are not only technically sound but also morally and socially responsible. These decisions often require a nuanced understanding of societal norms and ethics. In the video, the speaker points out that software engineering often involves such considerations, which AI currently lacks the ability to fully comprehend and apply.

💡AI Development

AI development refers to the process of designing, building, and deploying artificial intelligence systems. The video suggests that as AI evolves, there will be an increased demand for professionals who can create, update, and manage these systems, indicating that highly skilled software engineers will be in great demand in the AI sector.

💡Competency Curve

The competency curve represents the distribution of skills or expertise across a population, with the most skilled individuals on the far right. In the video, the speaker uses the concept of the competency curve to discuss the future of software engineering jobs, suggesting that those at the higher end of the curve will be more secure and valuable in the evolving job market.

💡Feedback Loop

A feedback loop is a process where output from a system is returned as an input, creating a cycle of continuous improvement. In the context of the video, the speaker discusses the importance of the feedback loop between AI and human software engineers, where the engineers help refine and improve AI-generated code to better meet requirements.

💡Programming Jobs

Programming jobs refer to the various roles and positions within the software development industry that involve writing, testing, and maintaining code. The video addresses the concern that some programming jobs may be replaced by AI-generated code, but also highlights the potential for new, more technical jobs to emerge as AI technology advances.

Highlights

Retired software engineer Dave shares his insights on the future of programming jobs.

Some programming jobs are disappearing, but others will become more valuable with the advancement of AI.

High-level programmers who specialize in complex tasks are less likely to be replaced by AI.

The future of software engineering may involve more collaboration with AI to solve intricate problems.

AI is expected to take over the 'grunt work' of programming, freeing up engineers for more complex tasks.

The role of software engineers will evolve, focusing on areas where AI cannot replicate human creativity and problem-solving.

AI's coding abilities are improving, but they still struggle with unstructured problem-solving and understanding human needs.

Software engineers with a deep understanding of customer needs and societal norms will remain in demand.

The demand for professionals to build, update, and manage AI systems is likely to increase as AI evolves.

Programming jobs that require less skill will likely be replaced by AI-generated code.

Software engineers should aim to be indispensable and focus on the more complex aspects of development.

The future of software engineering is bright, with new opportunities emerging in the AI field.

Complex problem-solving, creativity, and human intuition are areas where human engineers excel over AI.

AI's current limitations in grasping human-centric design make custom software development still reliant on human engineers.

The most secure software engineering jobs will be those that focus on the higher end of the competency curve.

The shift in programming jobs due to AI will require engineers to adapt and specialize in areas that AI cannot easily replicate.

Dave's personal advice to his son and others considering a career in software engineering.

Create Stunning Images & Videos in Seconds！

Explore the latest Flux 1.1 model and powerful Flux tools.

Create Stunning Images & Videos in Seconds！Try It Free