Comic Publishers Passing Off AI Art As Original Work

Comic News
22 Jun 202316:01

TLDRIn this video, Sean, the owner of Comics Elite, discusses the rise of AI-generated comic book art and its ethical implications. He criticizes the deceptive practices of some publishers and artists who sell AI art as original human creations without disclosure. Sean emphasizes the importance of honesty and transparency in the comic book industry, warning that such deceptive tactics could harm the market for high-end collectibles. He advises collectors to do their due diligence and research the authenticity of the art before investing in potentially AI-generated works.

Takeaways

  • 🤖 AI-generated comic books and art are becoming more prevalent, raising concerns about their authenticity and ethical use.
  • 🚫 Some publishers and creators are using AI art without disclosing it, which is seen as deceptive and potentially harmful to the industry.
  • 📚 DC and Marvel have policies in place regarding AI art, influenced by Supreme Court rulings on copyright and AI-generated content.
  • 🎨 The value of collectibles is often determined by the human artist's work, and AI-generated art may undermine this value.
  • 🔍 It's important for consumers to do their research and ask questions to determine if the art they are purchasing is AI-generated.
  • 💬 Honesty and transparency are crucial when selling AI art; creators should be upfront about the source of their artwork.
  • 🚨 The use of AI in art can be seen as theft, as it often involves piecing together images from other artists' work without permission.
  • 🌐 There are instances where AI-generated art is being sold at high prices, falsely attributed to non-existent or newly created artists.
  • 🔍 Signs of AI-generated art may include sudden improvements in an artist's work, lack of a consistent art history, and certain visual anomalies.
  • 📉 The unethical use of AI in comic book art could potentially damage the market for high-end collectibles and the comic book industry as a whole.

Q & A

  • What is the main issue discussed in the video regarding AI-generated comic book art?

    -The main issue is the ethical and deceptive use of AI-generated art, which is being sold as high-end collectibles without disclosing that it's not created by a human artist.

  • How does the Supreme Court's ruling affect AI-generated art?

    -The Supreme Court has ruled that AI-generated art cannot be copyrighted, which has implications for the use and sale of such art.

  • What is Sean's stance on AI-generated comic book covers?

    -Sean disavows the use of AI-generated comic book covers in their current form, considering it unethical and a form of theft.

  • What is the importance of the human element in comic book art?

    -The human element, such as the artist's unique style and skill, often determines the value of a collectible, and AI-generated art lacks this personal touch.

  • How can collectors identify AI-generated comic book art?

    -Collectors can look for sudden improvements in an artist's work, lack of a history or presence on art platforms, and inconsistencies in the artwork, such as extra details or strange shadows.

  • What is the potential impact of AI-generated art on the comic book industry?

    -If supported in its current form, AI-generated art could potentially ruin the comic book market by devaluing the work of human artists and misleading collectors.

  • What does Sean suggest collectors do to protect themselves from AI-generated art?

    -Sean suggests that collectors do their research, ask questions, demand to know the artist's identity, and be aware of the dangers of AI-generated art.

  • What is the significance of the term 'AI art' in the context of the video?

    -In the context of the video, 'AI art' refers to images generated by artificial intelligence, which are often created by piecing together elements from existing artworks found on the internet.

  • Why is it important for sellers to be transparent about the origin of their comic book art?

    -Transparency is important because it allows collectors to make informed decisions about their purchases, ensuring they are not investing in AI-generated art if they are seeking original human-created pieces.

  • What is the role of the AI in creating comic book covers?

    -AI plays a role by generating images based on prompts and existing artwork, but it does not create original content; it merely combines and smooths out elements from other sources.

  • How does the use of AI-generated art affect the value of comic book collectibles?

    -The value of collectibles is often tied to the human artist's work, and AI-generated art lacks this unique human touch, which can lead to a devaluation of the collectible market if not disclosed.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 AI Art and Ethical Concerns in Comic Books

The paragraph discusses the rise of AI-generated art in the comic book industry, particularly focusing on AI-generated comic covers. The speaker expresses concern about the ethical implications of selling AI art as if it were created by human artists, emphasizing the importance of honesty and transparency in the industry. The speaker criticizes those who do not disclose the AI origin of their art and highlights the potential damage to the value of collectibles and the reputation of artists.

05:01

🤝 The Impact of AI on Artistic Integrity

This paragraph continues the discussion on AI-generated art, highlighting specific instances where AI art has been deceptively marketed. The speaker shares personal experiences of questioning the authenticity of AI art and the subsequent backlash from fans and creators. The paragraph also touches on the lack of transparency from sellers who do not admit to using AI, and the potential for AI to disrupt the comic book market by undermining the value of human artistry.

10:02

🔍 Identifying AI Art and Its Implications

The speaker provides advice on how to identify AI-generated art and the importance of doing so for collectors and fans. They discuss the rapid advancement of AI technology and how it can mimic the style of human artists, making it difficult to distinguish between AI and human-created art. The paragraph also addresses the potential for AI to save costs in comic book production, which could lead to a decline in the quality and authenticity of comic book art.

15:02

🙏 Final Thoughts on AI Art in Comics

In the concluding paragraph, the speaker thanks the guest for discussing the issue of AI-generated comic covers. They reiterate the need for awareness and caution when dealing with AI art in the comic book industry. The speaker encourages collectors to ask questions and demand transparency from sellers regarding the origin of the art. They also stress the importance of supporting genuine human artistry and being aware of the potential negative impact of AI-generated art on the industry.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI-generated scripts

AI-generated scripts refer to the use of artificial intelligence to create written content, such as comic book scripts. In the video, this concept is discussed in the context of the evolving comic book industry, where AI is being used to generate content, raising ethical concerns about originality and authorship.

💡AI-generated comic books

These are comic books whose content, including artwork and storylines, is created by artificial intelligence rather than human artists and writers. The video highlights the growing trend of AI-generated comic books and the deceptive practices some publishers may use to sell them as original human creations.

💡Copyright

Copyright is a legal right that protects original works of authorship, including artistic creations. In the context of the video, the Supreme Court's ruling on AI art copyright is mentioned, indicating that AI-generated works cannot be copyrighted in the same way as human creations.

💡Ethical concerns

Ethical concerns in this context refer to the moral implications of using AI to create and sell comic book art without transparently disclosing its AI origin. The video argues for honesty and integrity in the comic book industry, especially when it comes to the authenticity of the artwork.

💡Art theft

Art theft in the AI context refers to the practice of AI algorithms using existing artworks as a basis for generating new images, which can be seen as stealing or plagiarizing the original artist's work. This is a significant issue discussed in the video, as it undermines the value of original human creativity.

💡Fake artist names

The use of fake artist names is a deceptive practice where publishers or creators attribute AI-generated art to non-existent human artists. This is highlighted in the video as a dishonest way to sell AI art as if it were created by a real person.

💡Collectibles

In the context of the video, collectibles refer to comic books and other related items that are sought after by collectors for their rarity, artistic value, and potential to appreciate in value over time. The authenticity of these collectibles is crucial, and the video discusses how AI-generated art can mislead collectors.

💡Due diligence

Due diligence in this context means the responsibility of buyers and collectors to research and verify the authenticity of the art they are purchasing. The video encourages viewers to do their own research to avoid being misled by AI-generated art.

💡AI art generation

AI art generation is the process by which artificial intelligence algorithms create visual art. This can involve using existing images as a basis for new creations or generating images from scratch based on user input. The video discusses the rapid advancement of AI art generation and its impact on the comic book industry.

💡Honesty in art

Honesty in art refers to the integrity of creators and publishers in accurately representing the origin and nature of the artwork they produce and sell. The video emphasizes the importance of being transparent about the use of AI in art creation to maintain trust and ethical standards.

Highlights

Sean, owner of Comics Elite, discusses the rise of AI-generated comic books and art.

DC and Marvel have policies regarding AI-generated art due to Supreme Court rulings on AI and copyright.

Some individuals are creating and selling AI-generated comic books without disclosing their AI origin.

Sean emphasizes the importance of creating comics ethically and honestly.

AI art is created by stealing images from the internet and piecing them together, not by original creation.

Sean disavows the use of AI-generated covers in his comic store and publishing companies.

The value of collectibles is often determined by the human artist's work, which AI-generated art bypasses.

Sean criticizes the deceptive practice of selling AI art as high-end collectibles without transparency.

Some sellers create fake artist names for AI-generated art to avoid admitting its AI origin.

Sean shares his experience of being blocked for questioning the authenticity of an AI-generated cover.

AI-generated art often lacks the history and development of a real artist's work.

Sean warns that AI-generated art could potentially ruin the comic book industry if not properly disclosed.

He advises collectors to do their due diligence and research the artist's history to avoid AI-generated art.

Sean suggests that AI-generated art should be clearly labeled and the original artists should be credited.

The transcript highlights the ethical and practical implications of AI-generated art in the comic book industry.