Google Gemini vs Google Assistant - Which One Is Better? (Tested On The Pixel 8 Pro)

In Depth Tech Reviews
16 Feb 202414:37

TLDRIn this video, the presenter conducts a detailed comparison between Google Assistant and Gemini, assessing their performance on a range of commands from basic to complex. The test is conducted on a Pixel 8 Pro for consistency. Google Assistant excels in everyday tasks, speed, and offline capabilities, while Gemini offers advantages in specific scenarios like email composition, template creation, and image generation. Despite some inaccuracies and inconsistencies, Google Assistant is recommended for routine use, with Gemini serving as a supplementary tool for less frequent needs.

Takeaways

  • 📌 Both Google Assistant and Gemini were tested on a Pixel 8 Pro for consistency.
  • 🕒 Google Assistant failed to start the stopwatch while Gemini couldn't control the stopwatch app.
  • 📱 Setting an alarm and turning off Bluetooth were successfully executed by both assistants.
  • 🤳 Gemini was unable to take a selfie as requested, whereas Google Assistant did not execute the command properly.
  • 🔄 Google Assistant made an error with the math calculation, while Gemini provided the correct answer.
  • 💌 Both assistants failed to message correctly on Valentine's Day, showing a lack of understanding of the command.
  • 📱 Google Assistant could send messages to a UAE number, but was unaware of the discontinuation of a feature.
  • 🚗 Google Assistant provided immediate navigation to a gas station, whereas Gemini required manual initiation of navigation.
  • 🕒 Google Assistant gave an incorrect time estimate to reach the Mall of Arabia, while Gemini provided the correct time but with a delay.
  • 📝 Gemini was more detailed and visually pleasing in providing information, especially for less common tasks.
  • 🏞 Google Assistant is more suitable for day-to-day tasks due to its speed and offline capabilities.
  • 🛠 Google Assistant is better for tasks like identifying products with Google Lens, while Gemini excels at email writing and template creation.

Q & A

  • What was the main purpose of the video?

    -The main purpose of the video was to compare the performance of Google Assistant and Gemini in executing basic, moderate, and complicated commands.

  • Which device were the assistants tested on?

    -The assistants were tested on the Pixel 8 Pro to ensure consistency.

  • How did the assistants perform when asked to set a timer for 5 minutes?

    -Both assistants failed to perform the task correctly. Google Assistant opened the right app but didn't start the stopwatch, while Gemini claimed it couldn't control apps like a stopwatch.

  • What was the outcome when the user asked to turn off Bluetooth?

    -Both assistants successfully turned off Bluetooth.

  • How did Google Assistant and Gemini handle the command to send a voice message to Imad on WhatsApp?

    -Both assistants attempted to use Google Assistant for the task but ended up sending a normal text message instead. They also did not mention that audio messaging would be discontinued.

  • Which assistant performed better when navigating to the nearest gas station?

    -Google Assistant performed better as it started the navigation automatically, while Gemini required the user to tap the screen to start navigation.

  • What was the issue with Google Assistant's response when asked to show the actors of The Godfather movie?

    -Google Assistant provided the director's name and the year of production but did not list the actors, whereas Gemini provided a list of main actors.

  • How did the assistants handle the command to create a cover letter template for a customer service manager job?

    -Google Assistant did not support this functionality, while Gemini provided a cover letter template with different writing styles.

  • Which assistant is more suitable for offline use?

    -Google Assistant is more suitable for offline use as it supports offline commands, while Gemini requires an internet connection for all commands.

  • What was the final verdict of the comparison between Google Assistant and Gemini?

    -Google Assistant was deemed better for normal day-to-day usage due to its speed and offline support, while Gemini was found more useful for specific tasks like writing emails, creating templates, or generating images.

Outlines

00:00

🤖 Google Assistant vs Gemini: Basic Commands Comparison

This paragraph introduces a video that compares Google Assistant and Gemini based on their ability to execute basic, moderate, and complex commands. The testing is conducted on a Pixel 8 Pro to maintain consistency. The evaluation system awards points for correct answers and extra points for better outcomes. The first command involves setting two timers, one for 5 minutes and another for 5 minutes as well, but both assistants fail to start the stopwatch. The second command sets an alarm at 7 a.m., which both assistants successfully execute. The paragraph details the shortcomings of both assistants in various tasks such as turning off Bluetooth, taking a selfie, adjusting screen brightness, and performing mathematical operations. Google Assistant's incorrect response to a subtraction and division task is highlighted, as well as Gemini's slower performance but correct answers. The paragraph concludes with a comparison of how both assistants handle sending messages and Valentine's Day wishes.

05:02

🚗 Navigation and Daily Tasks Management

This paragraph discusses the performance of Google Assistant and Gemini in navigation and managing daily tasks. Both assistants correctly identify the nearest gas station and provide directions. Google Assistant immediately initiates navigation, earning extra points for usefulness. When asked about the travel time to the Mall of Arabia, both provide similar answers, but Gemini incorrectly sets the time to turn off an air purifier. The paragraph also covers the assistants' abilities in setting bedtime routines, managing reminders, and reading notifications. It is noted that Gemini fails to process reminders and only reads new messages, similar to Google Assistant. Both assistants display the actors of 'The Godfather' movie and identify top-rated pizza restaurants, with Gemini providing a more visually pleasing response.

10:04

🌐 Advanced Features and Offline Support

The final paragraph explores more advanced and less common commands that could give Gemini an advantage. Gemini provides a more detailed response to a travel planning query, despite a technical issue with flight information. Google Assistant focuses on flights, while Gemini offers images and additional information. The paragraph also compares the assistants' capabilities in creating a hiking checklist, leaving for a destination at 5 a.m., and managing emails from Fitbit. Gemini's email summary and count are criticized for inaccuracy. The paragraph concludes with a comparison of creating a cover letter template, emailing help desk reports, photo generation, object identification, and product identification. Google Assistant's offline support is highlighted as a key advantage, and the overall verdict is that Google Assistant is superior for day-to-day use, while Gemini is better for specific, less frequent tasks.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Google Assistant

Google Assistant is an AI-powered virtual assistant developed by Google, designed to help users with various tasks such as setting reminders, answering queries, and controlling smart home devices. In the video, it is compared with Gemini to determine which assistant performs better in executing different commands, ranging from simple tasks like setting a timer to more complex ones like generating photos or planning a trip.

💡Gemini

Gemini is another virtual assistant featured in the video, which is compared against Google Assistant. It is noted for its capabilities in handling less frequent tasks such as creating email templates, generating images, and providing detailed information. However, its performance in day-to-day tasks and offline support is contrasted with Google Assistant's.

💡Comparison

The act of comparing two or more items to determine their differences and similarities. In the context of the video, the comparison is between Google Assistant and Gemini, assessing their performance in various tasks to identify which is superior in different scenarios.

💡Commands

Commands are instructions given to virtual assistants like Google Assistant and Gemini, which they execute to perform tasks. The video focuses on how well each assistant understands and carries out a range of commands from basic to complicated.

💡Virtual Assistant

A virtual assistant is an artificial intelligence agent that uses natural language processing and voice recognition to interact with users, performing tasks and providing information. The video centers on two such assistants, Google Assistant and Gemini, and evaluates their capabilities.

💡Performance

Performance refers to the effectiveness and efficiency with which a task is carried out. In the video, the performance of Google Assistant and Gemini is assessed based on their ability to accurately and quickly complete the given commands.

💡Day-to-Day Usage

Day-to-day usage refers to the regular, everyday tasks that people perform. In the context of the video, it highlights the practical and frequent use of Google Assistant for tasks like setting timers, alarms, and controlling device settings.

💡Offline Support

Offline support means the capability of a virtual assistant to function without an internet connection. In the video, this is a notable advantage of Google Assistant over Gemini, as it can perform certain tasks like starting a timer even without connectivity.

💡User Experience

User experience refers to the overall satisfaction and ease of use that a person has while interacting with a product or service. The video evaluates the user experience of Google Assistant and Gemini based on factors like speed, accuracy, and the need for manual intervention.

💡Smart Home Control

Smart home control involves the use of virtual assistants to manage and operate smart devices in a home, such as lights, thermostats, and security systems. In the video, this capability is tested by assessing how well the assistants can control apps and devices, like turning off an air purifier.

Highlights

The video presents a side-by-side comparison between Google Assistant and Gemini.

Both assistants were tested on a Pixel 8 Pro for consistency.

The first command involved setting timers, but both assistants failed to start the stopwatch.

Gemini was unable to control apps like the stopwatch, which is a notable limitation.

Both assistants successfully set an alarm at 7 a.m.

Google Assistant made an error by not accounting for the subtraction before division in the math command.

Google Assistant's continued conversation feature was noted for its convenience.

Gemini was slower and required tapping the mic for each command.

Both assistants failed to message someone for Valentine's Day correctly, with Google Assistant making an unexpected mistake.

Google Assistant will discontinue the audio messaging feature, which was a point of confusion.

Gemini was able to send a normal text message without mentioning the discontinued feature.

Google Assistant immediately provided driving directions to a gas station, which was more useful than Gemini's approach.

Gemini did not provide the correct time to leave for the Mall of Arabia due to an inconsistency in its response.

Google Assistant had better success with the flights to Spain query, despite Gemini providing a more detailed experience.

Gemini outperformed Google Assistant in creating a cover letter template and identifying objects.

Google Assistant's offline support was highlighted as a significant advantage over Gemini.

The video concludes that Google Assistant is better for day-to-day usage, while Gemini is useful for specific tasks.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now