Ideogram Ai vs Midjourney COMPARED Print on Demand

Philip Anders
18 Sept 202309:24

TLDRIn this video, the creator compares the AI art generation capabilities of Mid-Journey and Ideogram for print-on-demand designs. They test various prompts, noting that Ideogram excels in text accuracy but often falls short in graphic quality, while Mid-Journey produces superior graphics but struggles with text. The video highlights the strengths and weaknesses of each platform and provides tips for users to achieve better results, also addressing the commercial use of AI-generated content and clarifying Ideogram's terms of service.

Takeaways

  • 🔍 The video compares the AI design capabilities of Mid-Journey and Ideogram for print-on-demand prompts.
  • 🎨 Ideogram excels in text results, while Mid-Journey has better graphics, especially for long-standing AI image creation.
  • ✍️ A prompt for a fall design in the shape of a hat had a spelling error in Ideogram's result, but the style was liked enough to remix and correct.
  • 🐱 A simple prompt for 'cat in a coffee cup' resulted in a favorite design with correct spelling in Ideogram, but Mid-Journey's graphics were considered superior.
  • 🚀 Mid-Journey's graphics are market-leading, but Ideogram's text results are often more accurate.
  • 🎃 A Halloween t-shirt design prompt yielded better results in Ideogram, with more pleasing graphics for print-on-demand, despite Mid-Journey's sharper and more accurate output.
  • 🇺🇸 An American flag-themed design prompt worked well in Mid-Journey, but Ideogram's results had issues with text and graphic quality.
  • 🖼️ For a tall format wall art design, Ideogram's output was preferred over Mid-Journey's, despite the latter's higher quality.
  • 📜 Ideogram's terms of service are unclear regarding commercial use, but they do not restrict the use of generated content, as long as third-party intellectual property rights are not infringed.
  • 📝 Users should consider the need for permissions from third parties when using AI-generated content for commercial purposes.
  • 🌐 Ideogram's community and social media platforms have clarified that their services are not limited to personal use, addressing previous confusion.

Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the video?

    -The main purpose of the video is to compare the results of two AI design tools, Ideogram and Mid-Journey, for print-on-demand prompts.

  • Which AI tool performed better with text in the fall design prompt?

    -Ideogram performed better with text in the fall design prompt, despite a spelling error.

  • What is a quick tip mentioned in the video for improving results with Ideogram?

    -A quick tip mentioned is to use the remix function if you like the style of an image but there's a mistake, such as a spelling error.

  • How does the video creator describe the quality of Mid-Journey's graphics?

    -The video creator describes Mid-Journey's graphics as often having better quality because they've been around for a long time and are market-leading with AI images.

  • What is the issue with the text in the Halloween t-shirt design prompt when using Mid-Journey?

    -The issue with the text in the Halloween t-shirt design prompt when using Mid-Journey is that it is not spelled correctly, with 'stovy' instead of 'spooky'.

  • What is the recommendation for using AI-generated images for commercial purposes according to Ideogram's terms of service?

    -Ideogram's terms of service do not restrict the use of generated content for commercial purposes, but users should ensure they do not infringe on third-party intellectual property rights.

  • Which AI tool provided better results for the American flag-themed design prompt?

    -Mid-Journey provided better results for the American flag-themed design prompt, with more accurate and detailed graphics.

  • What is the video creator's opinion on the wall art design generated by Ideogram?

    -The video creator prefers the style of the wall art design generated by Ideogram, finding it more visually appealing despite Mid-Journey's higher quality.

  • What is the main difference between Ideogram and Mid-Journey in terms of text results?

    -Ideogram tends to provide better text results, while Mid-Journey excels in graphics, as seen in the comparison of their outputs.

  • How does the video creator suggest using the remix function in AI design tools?

    -The video creator suggests using the remix function to achieve more accurate results that match the desired style, especially when dealing with text or graphics that need refinement.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 AI Art Generators Comparison: Ideogram vs Mid-Journey

The video script compares two AI art generators, Ideogram and Mid-Journey, using various prompts to see which produces better results for print-on-demand designs. The first prompt tests a fall design in the shape of a hat, where Ideogram provides a visually appealing result but with a spelling error. Mid-Journey's result is inferior in terms of text quality. The script also discusses a prompt for a cat in a coffee cup, where Ideogram's text is correct and the graphics are appealing, while Mid-Journey's graphics are better but the text is incorrect. The comparison highlights that Ideogram excels in text results, while Mid-Journey has superior graphics. The script also touches on the commercial use of AI-generated images, clarifying that Ideogram does not restrict the use of generated content for commercial purposes, as long as it does not infringe on third-party intellectual property.

05:01

🇺🇸 American Flag Design and Ideogram's Terms of Service

The second paragraph continues the comparison by using a vintage retro American flag design prompt. The results from Ideogram are deemed superior for print-on-demand products, while Mid-Journey's graphics are more detailed but less suitable for the purpose. The script also addresses a concern about the commercial use of images generated by Ideogram, explaining that while the terms of service are unclear, Ideogram has clarified that users can use the generated content commercially, provided it does not infringe on third-party rights. The video concludes with a recommendation to check out a separate video for an in-depth overview of Ideogram.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Mid-Journey

Mid-Journey is an AI-based design tool that generates images based on user prompts. In the video, it is compared with Ideogram to determine which tool produces better results for print-on-demand purposes. The comparison focuses on aspects like text accuracy, graphic quality, and overall design appeal.

💡Ideogram

Ideogram is another AI design tool that is relatively new to the market. It is compared with Mid-Journey in the video, with a focus on its text generation capabilities and graphic quality. The video suggests that Ideogram excels in text results but may not always match Mid-Journey's graphic quality.

💡Print-on-Demand

Print-on-demand refers to a business model where products are printed as orders are received, reducing inventory and waste. In the context of the video, it is the primary use case for which the AI-generated designs are being evaluated, with considerations for text legibility and graphic appeal.

💡Prompts

Prompts are the input commands or descriptions given to AI design tools like Mid-Journey and Ideogram to generate specific images. The video discusses various prompts and the resulting designs, highlighting the effectiveness of each tool in interpreting and executing these prompts.

💡Text Accuracy

Text accuracy refers to the correctness of the text generated by the AI tools, including spelling and typography. The video emphasizes the importance of text accuracy for print-on-demand products, where mistakes can significantly impact the final product's quality.

💡Graphics Quality

Graphics quality pertains to the visual appeal, detail, and resolution of the images produced by the AI tools. The video compares the graphics quality of Mid-Journey and Ideogram, noting that while Mid-Journey often provides better graphics, Ideogram may excel in certain text-based designs.

💡Remix Function

The remix function allows users to modify existing designs by AI tools to create new variations. In the video, the remix function is used to correct a spelling error in a design, demonstrating the flexibility of the AI tools in refining user-generated content.

💡Commercial Use

Commercial use refers to the application of content for business or profit-making purposes. The video clarifies the terms of service for Ideogram, addressing concerns about whether AI-generated images can be used commercially. It suggests that as long as the images do not infringe on third-party intellectual property, they can likely be used for commercial purposes.

💡Intellectual Property

Intellectual property (IP) refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions, artistic works, designs, and symbols, used in commerce. The video mentions that users should be cautious about generating AI images related to celebrities or brands, as these may infringe on existing IP rights.

💡Terms of Service

Terms of service are the rules and guidelines set by a company for the use of its services. The video discusses the ambiguity in Ideogram's terms of service regarding commercial use, but it clarifies that the company does not restrict the commercial use of their platform's output, as long as no third-party IP is infringed.

Highlights

Comparison between Mid-Journey and Ideogram for print-on-demand prompts.

Mid-Journey excels in text results while Ideogram provides better graphics.

A fall design in the shape of a hat with a spelling error in Ideogram.

Remix function in Ideogram allows for style replication with corrected text.

Mid-Journey's results for the same prompt are inferior in terms of graphics.

Ideogram's simple prompt for a cat in a coffee cup with text 'Cappuccino' yields varied results.

Spelling errors are common in Ideogram's text results.

Mid-Journey's graphics are superior for the cat in a coffee cup prompt.

Graphics without text show less distortion in Ideogram.

Mid-Journey's graphics are more detailed and accurate but may not be ideal for print-on-demand.

Ideogram's Halloween t-shirt design with a skeleton is more pleasing for print-on-demand.

Mid-Journey's American flag themed design is more detailed but less suitable for print-on-demand.

Ideogram's wall art design with a minimalistic style is preferred over Mid-Journey's.

Ideogram's terms of service are unclear regarding commercial use of generated content.

Ideogram does not restrict commercial use of images, but users must avoid infringing on third-party intellectual property.

Recommendation to check out Ideogram for an overview and usage in designs.