Midjourney vs Leonardo vs Dall-E 3 vs Adobe Firefly [Best Image Generator in 2024]

WieseTechnology
26 Dec 202320:05

TLDRIn a comparison of the best image generators in 2024, Midjourney takes the lead with 14 points, followed by Adobe Firefly with 11.5 points and Dall-E 3 with 9.5. The evaluation is based on realism, adherence to prompts, and user interface. Midjourney excels in generating detailed and realistic images, despite some competitors like Firefly offering a more user-friendly interface. Pricing also plays a role, with Leonardo providing the most credits daily, but Midjourney's powerful image generation capabilities give it the edge.

Takeaways

  • 🏆 Mid Journey won the comparison with a total of 14 points, followed by Dall-E 3 with 9.5 points and Adobe Firefly with 11 points.
  • 🐘 In the 'realistic animal' category, Mid Journey and Adobe Firefly performed better than Dall-E 3 and Leonardo.
  • 🌄 For 'realistic landscape', Mid Journey and Leonardo were favored over Dall-E 3 and Firefly, with Mid Journey taking the lead.
  • 👩‍🦰 In 'realistic person portrait', Adobe Firefly and Mid Journey were superior, while Dall-E 3's entry was deemed unrealistic.
  • 📸 For 'realistic object', Dall-E 3 was rated the most realistic, followed by Adobe Firefly and Mid Journey.
  • 🍞 In 'realistic food', Leonardo and Adobe Firefly were preferred over Mid Journey and Dall-E 3 for their depiction of freshly baked bread.
  • 👤 A simple 'man' prompt was best interpreted by Mid Journey and Leonardo, with Firefly's realistic approach coming in second.
  • 🚀 Dall-E 3 and Mid Journey excelled in creating 'futuristic cyberpunk art', with Dall-E 3 receiving an additional point.
  • ☕ Mid Journey was the top choice for 'minimalistic logo creation', followed by Dall-E 3, while Adobe Firefly was considered too elaborate.
  • 🖼️ For 'text in the image', Dall-E 3 was the clear winner, accurately creating the requested sign, while Mid Journey and Adobe Firefly came in second.
  • 🎨 In 'abstract art', Mid Journey was favored for its vibrant and geometric design, with Adobe Firefly and Leonardo sharing second place.
  • 🌊 The 'watercolor painting' category was a close call, with Dall-E 3 and Mid Journey sharing the top spot, and Leonardo in second place.
  • 🤖 Following complex prompts, Dall-E 3 was the standout performer, creating images that closely matched the detailed descriptions given.
  • 🛠️ In terms of ease of use, Dall-E 3 was the most beginner-friendly with its simple chat-based interface, while Leonardo was the most complex.
  • 💰 Pricing-wise, Leonardo offered the best value with 150 daily credits, followed by Adobe Firefly at $6 a month, and Mid Journey at $10 a month for 250-300 image generations.

Q & A

  • Which image generator won the first place in the comparison?

    -Mid Journey won the first place in the comparison with a total of 14 points.

  • What was the prompt for the first image comparison, and which generator performed the best?

    -The prompt for the first image comparison was 'action shot of an elephant in the style of National Geographic'. Mid Journey performed the best in this category.

  • What issue did the reviewer find with DALL-E 3's generated elephant image?

    -The reviewer found that DALL-E 3's generated elephant image looked weird and not realistic at all.

  • How many images can DALL-E 3 create with a single prompt?

    -DALL-E 3 can create only one image with a single prompt.

  • What was the second image prompt, and which generator was given the first place for this category?

    -The second image prompt was 'photo of a beautiful landscape during golden hour'. Mid Journey was given the first place for this category.

  • What are the different picture categories that were reviewed in the video?

    -The different picture categories reviewed were realistic person portrait, realistic object, realistic food, simple one or two-word prompt, futuristic cyberpunk art, minimalistic logo creation, creating text in the image, abstract art, watercolor style art, and following a relatively complex prompt.

  • Which image generator was best at creating realistic person portraits according to the reviewer?

    -According to the reviewer, Firefly was best at creating realistic person portraits.

  • What was the prompt for the futuristic cyberpunk art category, and which generator received the most points for this prompt?

    -The prompt for the futuristic cyberpunk art category was 'illustration of a futuristic cyberpunk city with cyberpunk gadgets and technology, intense colors, very detailed'. Mid Journey received the most points for this prompt.

  • How does the user interface of DALL-E 3 compare to the others in terms of ease of use?

    -DALL-E 3's user interface is considered unbeatable in terms of ease of use because it has the simplest user interface, allowing users to just tell Chat GPT what to do.

  • What are the subscription prices for Mid Journey and DALL-E 3, and what do they include?

    -Mid Journey's subscription is $10 a month for roughly 200 image generations, and $30 a month for unlimited generations with limited fast hours. DALL-E 3's subscription is $20 a month, which includes all of what comes with Chat GPT plus, but as of December 2023, subscriptions are paused.

Outlines

00:00

🏆 Image Generator Competition

The script introduces a competition among different image generators: Dy 3, Mid Journey, Firefly, and Leonardo, based on their ability to create realistic images. The narrator compares the generators using various prompts such as an elephant in National Geographic style, a landscape during golden hour, and a realistic portrait of a woman with red hair. The evaluation criteria include realism, prompt accuracy, and the quality of the images produced. The script also mentions the ease of use and pricing of each generator, which will be discussed later.

05:02

🎨 Artistic and Realism Evaluation

This paragraph continues the comparison of image generators, focusing on different artistic styles and realism. It includes assessments of prompts for realistic objects, food, simple prompts, futuristic cyberpunk art, minimalistic logo creation, and abstract art. The narrator provides personal opinions on which generator performed best for each category, often giving first and second place rankings. The paragraph also discusses the user interface and ease of use for each generator, with a brief mention of pricing plans.

10:04

🤖 Futuristic and Abstract Image Creation

The script delves into the generators' capabilities to create futuristic and abstract images. It discusses the results of prompts for a futuristic cyberpunk city and abstract art with geometrical and neon elements. The narrator evaluates the generators based on personal preference and the ability to follow complex prompts accurately. The paragraph also includes a brief comparison of the user interfaces of the different generators, highlighting the ease of use for beginners and advanced users.

15:07

💰 Pricing and User Interface Overview

The final paragraph provides an overview of the pricing plans and user interfaces of the image generators. It discusses the subscription costs, the number of image generations included, and the features offered at different pricing tiers. The narrator also ranks the generators based on their user interfaces, considering both beginner-friendliness and the ability to fine-tune settings for advanced users. The script concludes with a summary of the points awarded to each generator, declaring Mid Journey as the winner with the most points.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Midjourney

Midjourney is an AI image generator that creates images based on textual prompts. It is one of the core subjects of the video, where its performance is compared with other image generators like Dall-E 3, Leonardo, and Adobe Firefly. The video discusses the quality and realism of images produced by Midjourney in various categories, such as realistic animal pictures, landscapes, and abstract art.

💡Dall-E 3

Dall-E 3 is another AI image generator developed by OpenAI. It is compared to Midjourney, Leonardo, and Adobe Firefly in terms of the realism and quality of the images it generates. The video highlights that Dall-E 3 has a simple user interface and can be very beginner-friendly, allowing users to describe what they want and receive an image in response.

💡Adobe Firefly

Adobe Firefly is a generative AI tool developed by Adobe that is capable of creating images from text prompts. In the context of the video, Firefly is evaluated on its ability to produce realistic and detailed images across various categories. It is noted for its ease of use and the fact that it is free to use, although watermarks are added to images unless a subscription is purchased.

💡Leonardo

Leonardo is an AI image generator that is part of the comparison in the video. It is discussed in terms of its ability to create images that are realistic and follow the prompts given to it. The video also mentions that Leonardo has a more complex interface with many settings that can be adjusted, which might be overwhelming for beginners but allows for a high degree of customization for advanced users.

💡Realism

Realism in the context of this video refers to the ability of the AI image generators to create images that closely resemble real-world objects, scenes, or people. The script evaluates each generator's output based on how accurately and authentically it represents the subject matter, such as in prompts for landscapes, food, or portraits.

💡User Interface

The user interface, or UI, is the part of a software system that users interact with. In the video, the UI of each image generator is discussed in terms of its ease of use and how beginner-friendly it is. Dall-E 3 is noted for having a very simple UI, while Leonardo's UI is described as more complex and potentially overwhelming for new users.

💡Pricing

Pricing refers to the cost of using each of the AI image generators. The video provides an overview of the subscription costs for Dall-E 3, Midjourney, and Leonardo, as well as the cost to remove watermarks from Adobe Firefly images. It discusses the value for money that each service offers in relation to the number of image generations included in their plans.

💡Image Generation

Image generation is the process by which AI tools create images based on textual descriptions or prompts. The video script discusses the quality and variety of images generated by each tool, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each in producing realistic, detailed, and accurate visuals.

💡Prompt

A prompt in the context of AI image generation is the textual description or command given to the AI tool to guide the creation of an image. The script uses various prompts to test the capabilities of each image generator, such as creating a 'realistic portrait photo of a cute woman with red hair' or 'a futuristic cyberpunk city.'

💡Cyberpunk

Cyberpunk is a genre of science fiction that features advanced technological and scientific achievements, juxtaposed with a degree of breakdown or radical change in the social order. In the video, a 'futuristic cyberpunk city' is used as a prompt to test the AI generators' ability to create detailed and stylistically consistent images that fit within the cyberpunk aesthetic.

Highlights

Mid Journey wins the first place with a total of seven points for creating the most realistic images.

Dall-E 3's image of an elephant appears weird and not realistic.

Firefly's elephant image has an anatomically incorrect leg.

Leonardo's elephant image has only three legs, possibly indicating an injury.

Mid Journey and Firefly are the top two image generators for realism in landscapes.

Dall-E 3 only creates one image at a time, which is a disadvantage compared to others.

Firefly is the best at creating realistic portraits of people.

Mid Journey's user interface is powerful but has a learning curve for advanced features.

Dall-E 3 has a simple and beginner-friendly user interface.

Leonardo's interface is complex and not beginner-friendly.

Mid Journey wins the category for creating the best minimalistic logo.

Dall-E 3 is consistent in generating the correct text for images.

Firefly is the most affordable option at $6 a month with watermark-free images.

Leonardo offers 150 free credits daily, making it a cost-effective choice.

Mid Journey's subscription is $10 a month for 200-300 image generations.

Dall-E 3's subscription is $20 a month, but currently, it's not available for new subscribers.

Mid Journey wins the overall competition with a total of 14 points.

The video includes a tutorial on how to adjust Dall-E 3 images for better results.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now