Print on Demand Design AI Showdown: Adobe Firefly vs Midjourney V5 The Ultimate Test

Brand Creators
18 Apr 202317:33

TLDRIn this video, the host puts Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5 to the test by creating print-on-demand designs with five different prompts. Adobe Firefly is currently in beta and not for commercial use, while Midjourney V5 is commercially available on their paid plan. The host compares the outputs of both AIs for prompts like 'bass fish jumping with water splashing' and 'horse galloping silhouette with floral flowers'. Midjourney V5 provides more realistic and detailed results, while Adobe Firefly offers versatility with different styles and the ability to make adjustments easily. However, for the desired line art and simpler designs, Midjourney V5 seems to deliver closer to the host's expectations without extensive reworking. The host concludes that, as of now, Midjourney V5 is the preferred choice for creating designs for print-on-demand, but acknowledges that Adobe Firefly will likely improve with future updates.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 **Adobe Firefly vs Midjourney V5**: A comparison of two AI design tools for creating print-on-demand designs.
  • 🚀 **Adobe Firefly Beta Limitation**: Currently, Adobe Firefly cannot be used for commercial purposes during its beta phase, but commercial use is expected upon release.
  • 💰 **Midjourney V5 Commercial Use**: Midjourney V5 is commercially available for users on their paid plan.
  • 🐟 **First Prompt Test**: A prompt for a bass fish jumping with water splashing was used to test both AIs, with a focus on creating line art for print-on-demand products.
  • 🔍 **Adobe Firefly Interface**: Offers a variety of styles and the ability to generate images directly from text prompts.
  • 📈 **Midjourney V5 Realism**: Initially produced more realistic images, which were not the desired outcome for the user's line art preference.
  • 🌿 **Succulent and Cactus Test**: Both AIs were tasked with creating individual elements for a cohesive design, with Adobe Firefly offering more immediate style adjustments.
  • 🎨 **Artistic Adjustments**: The user experimented with adding 'cartoon' and 'digital art' styles to the prompts for a more stylized result.
  • 🏡 **Farm Scene Challenge**: Creating a farm scene was more challenging, with Midjourney V5 providing a closer match to the desired outcome without extensive tweaking.
  • ✅ **Winner Selection**: The user found Midjourney V5 to be closer to their desired results out of the gate, requiring less reworking.
  • 📚 **Final Thoughts**: While Adobe Firefly offers more immediate editing options, the user's preference for the end product leans towards Midjourney V5's output.

Q & A

  • What is the main focus of the video?

    -The main focus of the video is a comparison between Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5 for creating print on demand designs, using five different prompts.

  • What is the current limitation of Adobe Firefly in its beta version?

    -In its beta version, Adobe Firefly cannot be used for commercial purposes. However, once it is taken out of beta, commercial use will be available.

  • What is the commercial availability status of Midjourney V5?

    -Midjourney V5 is commercially available for use if the user is on their paid plan.

  • What is the first prompt the video creator uses to test the design tools?

    -The first prompt used is for a 'bass fish jumping with water splashing from tail on a white background'.

  • Why does the video creator choose a white background for the design?

    -The white background is chosen because it is easier to cut out in editing tools like Canva or Photoshop for further use in print on demand products.

  • What feature does Adobe Firefly offer that allows for different looks without changing the prompt?

    -Adobe Firefly offers the ability to select different styles, such as 'art' or 'cartoon', which can alter the look of the generated design without modifying the prompt itself.

  • What does the video creator suggest to get a better result from Adobe Firefly?

    -The video creator suggests specifying the desired style, such as 'line art drawing' or 'cartoon', directly in the prompt for better initial results from Adobe Firefly.

  • Which tool provided more realistic results in the initial test?

    -Midjourney V5 provided more realistic results in the initial test without needing additional prompt adjustments.

  • What is the main difference between the outputs of Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5?

    -Adobe Firefly's outputs tend to require more tweaking to achieve the desired style, while Midjourney V5's outputs are closer to the desired look from the start.

  • What does the video creator conclude about the winner between Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5?

    -The video creator concludes that, as it stands, Midjourney V5 is closer to what they are looking for without extensive reworking. However, they acknowledge that Adobe Firefly may improve with future adjustments.

  • What is the video creator's final recommendation for users interested in creating print on demand designs?

    -The video creator recommends watching another video where they walk through creating a design from scratch and turning it into multiple products for further guidance.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Testing Adobe Firefly and Mid-Journey for Print-on-Demand Designs

The video begins with the host's intention to test Adobe Firefly and Mid-Journey version 5 for creating print-on-demand designs. Five different prompts will be tested in a direct comparison. The host notes that Adobe Firefly is in beta and not for commercial use yet, while Mid-Journey version 5 is commercially available for paid users. The first prompt involves creating a design for bass fishing, which is popular on Etsy. The host enters a description into Adobe Firefly and Mid-Journey to generate images, with a preference for a white background to facilitate editing in other tools. The results from both platforms are showcased, and the host discusses the differences and potential uses for each.

05:02

🔍 Exploring Prompt Variations and Style Selections

The host continues the video by experimenting with different prompts and style selections within Adobe Firefly and Mid-Journey. After generating a bass fish image, adjustments are made to the prompt to achieve a more line art style, which is preferred for print-on-demand products. The host also tests a horse galloping with floral flowers and a succulent in a terracotta pot, comparing the outputs from both platforms. It is observed that additional commands in the prompt can significantly change the style of the generated images. The host appreciates the ease of tweaking and getting different looks in Adobe Firefly without altering the prompt, while Mid-Journey requires more specific instructions for achieving a desired artistic style.

10:04

🌵 Creating a Cactus and Farm Scene with Adobe Firefly and Mid-Journey

The host attempts to create a cactus and a farm scene using both Adobe Firefly and Mid-Journey. The cactus prompt is adjusted to achieve a more cartoonish look, and the farm scene is described in detail to generate a line art drawing. The host notes the differences in the level of detail and the artistic style between the outputs of the two platforms. Adobe Firefly's results are compared with Mid-Journey's, with the latter providing a more detailed and realistic output initially. However, by adjusting the prompt and making it less detailed, the host is able to achieve a closer match to the desired outcome in Adobe Firefly.

15:05

🏆 Mid-Journey Version 5 Outperforms Adobe Firefly in Direct Comparison

In the final analysis, the host concludes that Mid-Journey version 5 has produced results closer to the desired aesthetic without extensive reworking, making it the preferred choice for this particular test. The host acknowledges that Adobe Firefly is still in beta and expects it to improve with future adjustments. The video ends with an invitation for viewers to watch another video where the host will guide them through creating a design from scratch and turning it into multiple products.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Print on Demand

Print on Demand (POD) refers to a printing technology and business model in which products are not printed until a confirmed order is received. This allows businesses to reduce inventory costs and only produce items as they are sold. In the video, the host is testing two AI design tools, Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5, to create designs for print on demand products.

💡Adobe Firefly

Adobe Firefly is a beta version of a design tool developed by Adobe that uses AI to generate images based on text prompts. It is currently not available for commercial use during its beta phase but is expected to be usable for commercial purposes once it is fully released. In the video, the host uses Adobe Firefly to create various design prompts for print on demand items.

💡Midjourney V5

Midjourney V5 is an AI tool that is capable of generating images from text prompts. It is mentioned in the video that Midjourney V5 is commercially available for use on their paid plan. The host compares its output with Adobe Firefly to determine which tool creates better results for print on demand designs.

💡Text to Image

Text to Image is a feature within AI design tools that allows users to input a descriptive text prompt and receive generated images that match the description. This feature is central to the video, as the host uses it to test the capabilities of both Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5 in creating print on demand designs.

💡Line Art

Line Art refers to a type of two-dimensional artwork that consists of nothing but lines, often used to create a silhouette or outline of an image. In the video, the host uses the term 'line art' in the prompts to request designs that are more stylized and less photorealistic, which is suitable for certain print on demand products.

💡Commercial Use

Commercial use implies the utilization of a product, service, or technology for monetary gain or business purposes. The video discusses the commercial use of the designs generated by the AI tools, noting the current restrictions of Adobe Firefly in beta and the availability of Midjourney V5 for such purposes.

💡Beta Version

A beta version of a product is a pre-release version that is given to a group of users for testing purposes before its official release. The video mentions that Adobe Firefly is in its beta phase, which is why it currently has limitations on commercial use.

💡Canva

Canva is an online graphic design platform used to create visual content such as logos, posters, and social media graphics. In the video, the host mentions Canva as a tool that could be used to edit or adjust the images generated by the AI design tools for print on demand products.

💡Photoshop

Photoshop is a widely used software by Adobe for image editing and manipulation. It is mentioned in the video as another tool that could be used to further edit the AI-generated designs to fit the host's needs for print on demand items.

💡Etsy

Etsy is an e-commerce website focused on handmade or vintage items and craft supplies. The host refers to Etsy as a marketplace where print on demand products, such as those designed using AI tools, can be sold.

💡Cartoonish

Cartoonish describes a style of artwork that resembles cartoons, often characterized by exaggerated features and simplified forms. In the context of the video, the host is looking for designs with a more cartoonish or artistic look for certain print on demand products, which is achieved by adding specific prompts or adjusting the style settings in the AI tools.

Highlights

Adobe Firefly and Midjourney V5 are compared for creating print-on-demand designs.

Adobe Firefly is currently in beta and not for commercial use, while Midjourney V5 is commercially available on paid plans.

The first design prompt is for bass fishing, a popular theme on Etsy.

Adobe Firefly offers a 'text to image' feature within its beta version.

Midjourney V5 provides more realistic outputs compared to Adobe Firefly.

Adding 'line art' to the prompt improves the style of the output in both Adobe Firefly and Midjourney.

The horse galloping silhouette with floral flowers is the second prompt tested.

Adobe Firefly allows easy modification of styles with a click, without altering the prompt.

Midjourney V5's interface is more straightforward, with a single input for prompts.

Creating individual elements for print-on-demand items is often easier and more effective.

Adobe Firefly's 'cartoon' style option transforms the succulent design into a more playful theme.

Midjourney V5 requires additional input adjustments to achieve a cartoonish or artistic look.

The cactus design in Adobe Firefly can be further tweaked for a more desired outcome.

Midjourney V5's output for the cactus prompt is more aligned with the desired cartoonish style.

A farm scene with a barn, tractor, and cows is the final and most challenging prompt.

Adobe Firefly's detailed outputs may require post-processing in tools like Canva or Photoshop to meet specific design needs.

Midjourney V5's initial results are closer to the desired outcome, requiring less reworking.

In the final assessment, Midjourney V5 is favored for its out-of-the-gate results, though Adobe Firefly shows potential for improvement post-beta.