UDIO vs Sonauto vs SUNO : AI Music Maker Showdown Review, With One STUNNING Winner!

Red Ferret
11 Apr 202428:14

TLDRIn this showdown review, three AI music generation tools - Udio, Sonauto, and Suno - are compared based on their interfaces, ease of use, and output quality. Udio, the new contender, impresses with its detailed interface and comprehensive features, despite being in beta. Sonauto, while functional, appears less refined. Suno, backed by Microsoft, offers a strong community and a growing library but lacks the sophistication of Udio. Udio stands out with its ability to generate music with depth and control over song structure, potentially revolutionizing AI music creation.

Takeaways

  • 🎵 UDIO, Sonauto, and SUNO are three AI music maker apps with different features and interfaces.
  • 📈 SUNO has a simple interface and provides detailed information on the first page, allowing users to create short song clips quickly.
  • 📝 Custom mode in SUNO lets users input their own lyrics, style, and title for a more personalized song creation experience.
  • 🎶 Sonauto's interface is more basic, and it generates songs that may not fully align with the chosen genre, offering three versions of each song.
  • 🔧 UDIO is in beta and has a more comprehensive set of features, including the ability to extend tracks with intros, sections, and outros for a seamless song structure.
  • 🚀 UDIO's help section is more detailed, providing users with hints and guidance on using the app effectively.
  • 💡 UDIO allows for commercial use of the generated music without the need for a premium subscription, unlike SUNO which requires payment for commercial rights.
  • 👥 SUNO has a strong community aspect with active users sharing prompts and genre codes on platforms like Discord.
  • 📊 The competition between these AI music makers is heating up, with UDIO showing potential to be a game-changer in the music generation space.
  • 🛠️ Users should be specific with their genre choices when using these apps, as the algorithms are still learning to accurately interpret and produce diverse musical styles.

Q & A

  • Which three AI music maker applications are discussed in the review?

    -The three AI music maker applications discussed in the review are Sunno, Sonoro, and Audio.

  • How does the user interface of Sunno differ from that of Sonoro and Audio?

    -Sunno has a fairly plain user interface, Sonoro has a slightly more complex interface but still manageable, and Audio provides quite spectacular information on the first page without requiring the user to start up.

  • What are the custom mode options available in Sunno?

    -In Sunno's custom mode, users can enter their own lyrics, style, and title for the song. They can also add elements like Verse, Chorus, Bridge, and Solo.

  • How long does it typically take for Sunno to generate a song?

    -Sunno typically generates a song within 10 seconds or less.

  • What is unique about Audio's approach to music generation?

    -Audio's unique approach is that it seems to generate music on the fly as the user is viewing it, and it allows users to shape their song by adding an intro, sections before and after the clip, and an outro.

  • How long did it take for Audio to generate a song during the review?

    -During the review, it took Audio 48 minutes to generate a song.

  • What are the commercial rights implications for songs created with Sunno and Audio?

    -With Sunno, users do not get commercial rights to the songs unless they pay for a subscription. In contrast, with Audio, users retain commercial rights to the songs from the start, even during the beta phase.

  • What is the significance of the community aspect in Sunno?

    -The community aspect in Sunno is significant as it allows users to swap notes, share prompts, and genre codes, contributing to a rich and interactive user experience.

  • How does the reviewer describe the initial experience with Audio's music generation?

    -The reviewer describes the initial experience with Audio's music generation as stunning and a whole new ball game, indicating a high level of satisfaction with the quality and depth of the generated music.

  • What is the main challenge the reviewer sees with the current AI music generation applications?

    -The main challenge the reviewer sees is the AI's interpretation of categories and genres, as the algorithm sometimes struggles to generate music that accurately fits the requested genre.

Outlines

00:00

🎵 Overview of AI Music Generation Apps

This paragraph introduces three AI music generation applications: Sunni, Sonoro, and the new beta app, Udio. The comparison is based on their user interfaces, with Sunni being the most straightforward, Sonoro slightly more complex, and Udio offering detailed information. The focus is on how to start creating music with these apps, highlighting Sunni's approach of adding a description and choosing the custom mode for more detailed input like lyrics and style. The paragraph also discusses the immediate creation of two short song versions and the ability to add elements like verses and bridges in custom mode.

05:01

🎶 Sunni and Sonoro: Features and Functionality

The second paragraph delves into the specifics of Sunni and Sonoro, noting the basic and rudimentary user interface of Sonoro and its functionality. It contrasts Sunni's more sophisticated interface and the features it offers, such as the ability to extend songs, add to playlists, and report content. The paragraph also touches on the community aspect of Sunni, mentioning its active user base on platforms like Discord, where users share prompts and genre codes to create unique songs.

10:03

🎧 Udio: A Comprehensive and Advanced Platform

This paragraph provides an in-depth look at Udio, highlighting its impressive start screen and the variety of choices it offers, such as staff picks, trending tracks, and categories. It emphasizes Udio's comprehensive help section, which provides detailed guidance on using the app, including how to extend tracks and build a full song with added sections like intros, outros, and remix variations. The paragraph also discusses Udio's ownership and content rights, noting that users retain full control over their content and can use it for commercial purposes without restrictions.

15:05

🎼 Udio's Terms of Service and Content Rights

The paragraph outlines Udio's terms of service, focusing on the rights and restrictions associated with using the platform. It mentions the prohibition against using bots or misrepresenting affiliations to manipulate the system. The content rights section clarifies that while Udio owns the service, users own and control their content, allowing for both personal and commercial use without additional payment. The paragraph also covers promotional rights, attribution requirements, and standard disclaimers regarding warranties and third-party content.

20:07

🚀 Udio's Potential and Current Limitations

In this paragraph, the speaker reflects on Udio's potential to revolutionize music generation, comparing it to significant technological advancements in other fields. Despite some initial issues with genre interpretation, the speaker is impressed by Udio's structure and the control it offers users in building and extending their songs. However, the speaker also notes that Udio's algorithm may need further refinement to accurately produce songs in more specific or niche genres. The paragraph concludes with a mention of the platform's current challenges, such as server issues due to high traffic, indicating its popularity and potential for growth.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI Music Maker

AI Music Maker refers to artificial intelligence applications designed to create music autonomously or with minimal human input. In the context of the video, three such apps are being reviewed and compared: Sonauto, Sunno, and UDIO. These apps leverage AI algorithms to generate music based on user-provided prompts, such as genre, lyrics, and mood.

💡Sonauto

Sonauto is one of the music generation AI apps being reviewed. It is characterized by a slightly more complex interface compared to UDIO but still user-friendly. Users can input basic information to generate music, and the app provides options for creating songs with different structures like verses, choruses, and bridges.

💡Sunno

Sunno is a well-known music production AI app backed by Microsoft. It features a straightforward interface and allows users to create music by providing a description and choosing various options like instrumental versions. Sunno has a community aspect, with users able to share and discuss their creations, and it offers commercial rights to the songs for a subscription fee.

💡UDIO

UDIO is a new entrant in the AI music maker field, which has quickly gained attention for its advanced features and capabilities. Despite being in beta, it offers a comprehensive set of tools for users to create, extend, and customize their music. UDIO stands out for its ability to generate high-quality tracks and its focus on user control over the creative process.

💡Music Generation

Music Generation refers to the process of creating music using AI algorithms. It involves inputting various parameters such as genre, tempo, and lyrics into an AI music maker app, which then generates a unique musical piece. The video reviews three different AI music generation apps and compares their effectiveness and user experience.

💡Interface

In the context of the video, 'interface' refers to the visual and interactive elements of the AI music maker apps that users engage with to create music. The interfaces vary in complexity and design, affecting the user's experience and ease of use.

💡Custom Mode

Custom Mode is a feature in AI music maker apps that allows users to input their own lyrics, style, and other specific musical elements to create a personalized song. It provides a higher level of control and creativity compared to using preset options or templates.

💡Community

In the context of the video, 'Community' refers to the group of users who engage with each other and share their experiences, creations, and tips within the AI music maker apps. A strong community can enhance the app experience by providing support, inspiration, and feedback.

💡Commercial Rights

Commercial Rights in the context of AI-generated music refer to the legal permissions and ownership associated with using the created music for monetary gain. Some AI music makers require a subscription or payment to grant users the rights to use the generated music for commercial purposes, such as selling songs or using them in advertisements.

💡Beta

Beta refers to a testing phase for a product or service, indicating that it is not yet in its final form and may still undergo changes or improvements based on user feedback and testing. In the video, UDIO is described as being in beta, which explains its limitations and potential for future enhancements.

💡Music Review

A music review is a critical assessment or evaluation of music, often created by experts or enthusiasts, to provide opinions on its quality, creativity, and other aspects. In the video, a music review is conducted in the form of a showdown to determine which AI music maker app offers the best user experience and output.

Highlights

UDIO, Sonauto, and SUNO are three AI music maker applications currently available.

SUNO offers a simple interface and provides a lot of information on the first page.

In Sonauto, users can choose custom mode to input their own lyrics and style.

UDIO is in beta and offers a basic, no-frills interface.

SUNO generates music on the fly and typically produces tracks under one minute and thirty seconds long.

Sonauto's UI is rudimentary and it seems to struggle with genre interpretation.

UDIO, despite being in beta, produces high-quality music with depth and variety.

SUNO has a strong community with active engagement on platforms like Discord.

UDIO's interface has been upgraded to include features like staff picks and trending tracks.

UDIO allows users to have more control over building a song with options to add intros, sections, and outros.

UDIO provides comprehensive help and guidance for users, unlike the more rudimentary support offered by SUNO.

Users retain ownership and control of their content created on UDIO and can use it for commercial purposes.

UDIO's terms of service do not require users to be of a certain age, but do include standard legal disclaimers and restrictions.

SUNO requires a subscription for commercial use of the tracks, unlike UDIO which appears to allow it freely.

UDIO's structure and features represent a significant advancement in AI music generation compared to other apps.

The AI music generation field is rapidly evolving, with UDIO potentially marking a milestone in the technology.

UDIO's current challenge is improving its algorithm to accurately interpret a wider range of genres.

UDIO's server issues indicate high demand and traffic, which may lead to improvements in the future.