Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter Suspended (Good Job Kickstarter)

Steven Zapata Art
21 Dec 2022108:20

TLDRThe video discusses the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter campaign due to concerns over AI-generated images. The speaker praises Kickstarter's decision and contrasts it with ArtStation's response to similar issues. They also mention the Concept Art Association's GoFundMe campaign to protect artists from AI technologies and encourage donations. The conversation touches on the implications of AI for artists and the importance of ethical considerations in the use of AI in creative industries.

Takeaways

  • 😀 The 'Unstable Diffusion' Kickstarter project was suspended due to concerns over its methods, particularly scraping ArtStation for images to train its not-safe-for-work model.
  • 🚫 Suspension details highlight that Kickstarter halts projects under serious intellectual property or copyright claims, reflecting this situation.
  • 🎉 The suspension is celebrated by the streamer, who views it as a victory for artist integrity and a necessary action against potentially harmful AI practices in creative industries.
  • 🖼️ The incident has sparked a broader discussion on the ethics of AI in art, emphasizing the need for transparency and consent in data used for AI training.
  • 💬 The streamer encourages donations to the Concept Art Association's GoFundMe, aimed at protecting artists from AI technologies, suggesting community support is crucial.
  • 👥 Public and creator reactions are mixed, with some expressing relief and others sadness due to the project's suspension, illustrating the divisive nature of AI in art.
  • 🛑 The conversation extends to the responsibilities of platforms like ArtStation and DeviantArt in moderating content and protecting artists' rights.
  • 😡 There is notable frustration with ArtStation’s response to AI issues, pushing for more proactive measures and transparency from the platform.
  • 🌐 The streamer discusses the broader implications of AI, from ethical debates to specific concerns about AI’s role in creative fields like 3D modeling and texturing.
  • 📢 Advocacy for stricter regulations and ethical standards in AI development is a recurring theme, highlighting a community-driven push against unregulated AI expansion.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic discussed in the video?

    -The main topic discussed in the video is the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter campaign due to concerns about AI-generated art and its impact on artists.

  • What was the reaction of the speaker to the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter?

    -The speaker was supportive of the suspension, expressing approval for Kickstarter's decision and highlighting the importance of protecting artists' work from being exploited by AI technologies.

  • What is the role of the Concept Art Association's GoFundMe in this context?

    -The Concept Art Association's GoFundMe is mentioned as a platform for raising funds to protect artists from AI technologies, and the speaker encourages viewers to consider donating to support this cause.

  • What is the speaker's view on the current state of ArtStation?

    -The speaker expresses disappointment with ArtStation's handling of the AI issue, suggesting that it has not been as supportive of artists as Kickstarter has been.

  • What does the speaker suggest about the future of AI in 3D modeling?

    -The speaker suggests that while current AI technologies for 3D modeling are limited by the availability of 3D data sets, if genuine 3D model files were used to train AI, it could potentially produce high-quality 3D models with good topology.

  • What is the speaker's stance on AI-generated art?

    -The speaker is critical of AI-generated art, particularly when it involves non-consensual use of artists' work and threatens the market viability of original art.

  • What is the speaker's advice to artists in response to the rise of AI in the creative industries?

    -The speaker advises artists to continue creating and expressing their work, emphasizing that the act of drawing is valuable in itself, regardless of external circumstances.

  • How does the speaker feel about the general sentiment towards artists in society?

    -The speaker humorously suggests that artists are highly respected and admired in society, to the point of being celebrated and rewarded with prestigious honors and accolades.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on the importance of discussing AI in the art world?

    -The speaker believes that discussing AI and its implications for the art world is crucial, and that artists should stay informed and engaged in these conversations to protect their interests and rights.

  • What does the speaker suggest about the potential consequences of AI-generated art for artists?

    -The speaker suggests that AI-generated art could have significant consequences for artists, potentially affecting their market value and the originality of their work, and calls for ethical considerations and regulations in the development and use of AI technologies in the creative field.

Outlines

00:00

🎶 Music and Foreign Expressions

The paragraph begins with a series of expressions interspersed with musical notations, suggesting a spoken-word or rap-style script. The repetition of the word 'foreign' and the mention of 'my God' indicate a sense of awe or emphasis on something unexpected or out of the ordinary. The presence of music suggests an energetic or performative tone.

05:13

🗣️ Discussing Kickstarter and AI Technologies

This paragraph delves into a discussion about Kickstarter's recent actions regarding AI technologies, specifically表扬ing Kickstarter for their decision to suspend a project related to AI. The speaker also mentions the concept art association's GoFundMe campaign, advocating for donations and transparency in the use of funds. The paragraph touches on the challenges faced by artists due to AI technologies and the importance of supporting artists' rights in the face of these changes.

10:15

🚫 Suspension of Unstable Diffusion and its Implications

The speaker discusses the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion project on Kickstarter, expressing relief and approval of the decision. The conversation highlights the potential legal and ethical issues surrounding AI technologies, particularly in relation to data scraping and artist rights. The speaker also mentions the community's response on ArtStation and the broader implications of AI on the creative industry.

15:17

🎥 Sharing Personal Reactions and Future Plans

In this paragraph, the speaker shares personal reactions to the news of the suspension, including plans to discuss the issue on stream. The speaker expresses a desire to provide a safe space for backers of the Unstable Diffusion project to express their feelings and discusses the importance of solidarity among artists. The speaker also mentions personal actions, such as deleting an ArtStation account, as a statement against AI's impact on the art world.

20:17

🤔 Reflecting on AI's Impact on 3D Artists

The speaker ponders the impact of AI on 3D artists, noting that 3D modeling may currently be more difficult for AI due to the scarcity of 3D model data sets online. The conversation explores the potential for AI to generate 3D models based on 2D images, comparing the process to photogrammetry. The speaker also discusses the possibility of AI developing more advanced capabilities in the future if larger 3D data sets become available.

25:26

🎉 Celebrating a Victory and Contemplating Future Actions

The speaker celebrates the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter campaign and discusses the community's reaction, highlighting the positive feelings and sense of unity among artists. The speaker also contemplates future actions, including the possibility of sending ad money to support others in the community and the importance of continuing to spread the word about AI's impact on artists.

30:34

🌟 The Role of Ethics in AI and Texturing

The paragraph focuses on the ethical considerations of AI in texturing, suggesting that if AI is developed with consent from texture creators and proper licensing, it could be acceptable. The speaker emphasizes the need for labor regulations and the potential consequences of AI on the creative industry. The conversation also touches on copyright law and the fair use statute, questioning the legality of AI training in relation to copyrighted works.

35:35

💃 The Importance of Dancing and Morality

The speaker humorously suggests that dancing is the only ethically defensible position, using it as a metaphor for taking action and maintaining moral integrity in the face of AI's impact on the art world. The paragraph includes a call to join the 'scene' and celebrate, reflecting the speaker's positive and proactive attitude towards the situation.

40:36

🐶 Personal Anecdote and AI Ethics

The speaker shares a personal anecdote about discovering their dog using stable diffusion in the middle of the night, highlighting the complexities and challenges of discussing AI ethics within personal relationships. The speaker expresses hope for a conversation with their dog, symbolizing the need for understanding and dialogue on the topic of AI and its implications.

45:46

🎉 Continuing the Celebration and Addressing Critics

The speaker continues to celebrate the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter campaign, addressing critics and emphasizing the importance of supporting artists. The paragraph includes calls to action, such as supporting the concept art association's fundraiser and continuing to protest on ArtStation. The speaker also discusses the potential impact of AI on Patreon and the need for artists to adapt and privatize their work if necessary.

50:48

🎧 Listening to Music and Artistic Expression

The speaker shares their current musical preferences, which are heavily influenced by contemporary funk and disco. They mention listening to bands like Jungle and Tuxedo, reflecting a positive and upbeat mood. The speaker also discusses their recent podcast activities, including conversations about AI with various guests, highlighting their active engagement with the topic and the art community.

55:49

🤝 Empathy for AI Promoters and the Importance of Artist Clout

The speaker calls for empathy towards AI promoters, suggesting that resentment towards artists may stem from their elevated status and influence in society. The speaker humorously exaggerates the success and recognition of artists, emphasizing their importance and the increasing clout they hold. The paragraph ends with a call for artists to share their success and power with others, maintaining a sense of humor and self-awareness.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Unstable Diffusion

Unstable Diffusion refers to a specific AI model that was being developed and was the subject of a Kickstarter campaign. The model aimed to generate images using AI technology, but it faced controversy due to concerns about its potential impact on the art industry and the ethical issues surrounding AI-generated content. In the video, the speaker discusses the suspension of the Kickstarter campaign for Unstable Diffusion, which is seen as a positive development for artists and intellectual property rights.

💡Kickstarter

Kickstarter is a crowdfunding platform that allows creators to raise funds for their projects from the public. In the context of the video, Kickstarter is highlighted as a platform that has taken a stand against the Unstable Diffusion project by suspending it. This action is praised by the speaker as it supports artists and raises awareness about the potential negative impacts of AI-generated art.

💡AI-generated art

AI-generated art refers to the creation of visual or other artistic content using artificial intelligence algorithms. These AI models can produce images, music, literature, and more, often by learning from existing human-made works. The video discusses concerns about AI-generated art, particularly in relation to its potential to devalue human creativity and infringe on copyright laws.

💡ArtStation

ArtStation is an online platform where artists can showcase their work, find jobs, and connect with other professionals in the creative industry. In the video, ArtStation is mentioned as a place where there has been controversy surrounding AI-generated art and its impact on the community of artists. The speaker encourages artists to band together and take action against the use of AI-generated content on platforms like ArtStation.

💡Concept Art Association

The Concept Art Association is an organization that supports artists, particularly those working in the field of concept art. In the video, the speaker mentions a GoFundMe campaign by the Concept Art Association, which aims to protect artists from AI technologies. The campaign seeks donations to help artists navigate the changing landscape of their industry due to the rise of AI.

💡Intellectual Property

Intellectual property refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions, literary and artistic works, designs, and symbols, names, and images used in commerce. It is a legal concept that protects the rights of creators and owners over their creations. In the video, the suspension of the Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter campaign is linked to concerns about intellectual property rights, as AI-generated art can potentially infringe on these rights.

💡Data Acquisition

Data acquisition refers to the process of gathering, collecting, and storing data. In the context of AI, this often involves training AI models with large datasets. The video discusses the ethical concerns surrounding data acquisition for AI, particularly when it involves using existing artworks without the consent of the artists, which can lead to the creation of AI-generated art that may infringe on artists' rights.

💡Fair Use

Fair use is a legal doctrine that permits the use of copyrighted material without obtaining permission from the rights holder under certain conditions. It is a part of copyright law that allows for flexibility in the use of creative works for purposes such as criticism, commentary, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. In the video, the speaker mentions fair use in the context of AI training and its potential impact on the market value of copyrighted works.

💡Artists' Rights

Artists' rights refer to the legal and moral entitlements of artists to control and benefit from their creative works. These rights include copyright, the right to privacy, and the right to prevent the misuse of an artist's identity or work. In the video, the speaker emphasizes the importance of protecting artists' rights in the face of AI-generated art, which can potentially undermine the value and originality of artists' work.

💡Community Action

Community action refers to the collective efforts of a group of individuals to address a common issue or concern. In the video, the speaker highlights the role of the art community in raising awareness and taking action against the potential negative impacts of AI-generated art. This includes protests, fundraisers, and other forms of activism aimed at protecting artists' rights and intellectual property.

Highlights

Unstable Diffusion Kickstarter project suspended

Kickstarter praised for responding to concerns about AI-generated art projects

ArtStation's stance on AI technologies criticized

Concept Art Association's GoFundMe to protect artists from AI technologies

Discussion on the impact of AI on the quality of images on Kickstarter projects

Concerns about AI threatening the authenticity and originality of art projects

Kickstarter's decision to suspend the project seen as a step in the right direction

Mention of protests on ArtStation against AI

Discussion on the potential legal implications of using AI in art projects

Artists expressing their frustration and sadness over the suspension of the Kickstarter project

The importance of ethical considerations in the development and use of AI technologies

Concerns about the future of 3D art in the face of AI advancements

Discussion on the potential of AI to generate pornographic content

Artists urged to continue creating and expressing themselves despite the challenges

The impact of AI on the job security and market value of artists

The role of community and collective action in addressing the issues surrounding AI in art

The importance of maintaining a human touch in art and creativity