Earth 2 Metaverse situation is insane

Callum Upton
23 Sept 202426:52

TLDRThe video discusses the ongoing issues with Earth 2, a metaverse project that's facing regulatory hurdles, withdrawal problems, and accusations of intentional misconduct. The company's decision to switch to a cryptocurrency-only payout system has upset users, and the removal of a key feature, land income tax, has further eroded trust. Recent layoffs and a critical login bug exposing user data have deepened concerns, with some predicting Earth 2's downfall within months.

Takeaways

  • 🌐 The Earth 2 metaverse has been facing numerous issues, including withdrawal problems and regulatory compliance.
  • 🚫 Earth 2's withdrawal system has been suspended, and they've introduced a cryptocurrency withdrawal system that's been poorly received by the community.
  • 💸 There's a daily limit of £5,000 for cryptocurrency withdrawals, which is a shared limit for all users, causing significant delays for those wanting to cash out.
  • 🏦 Earth 2 has removed the land income tax feature, which was a primary source of profit for many users, without explanation.
  • 😵‍💫 Users are becoming increasingly frustrated and distrustful due to the lack of transparency and communication from Earth 2's team.
  • 🛑 Several developers have claimed they were let go by Earth 2 without receiving payment for their work.
  • 🔐 A recent change in the authentication system led to a security breach where users could access other users' accounts.
  • 👨‍💻 A respected moderator was removed and then banned from the Earth 2 Discord server after questioning the team's decisions.
  • 🐉 Earth 2 has been promoting superficial updates like new skins and features while ignoring more serious underlying issues.
  • 📉 There's a prediction that Earth 2 could collapse within four months due to financial mismanagement and loss of user confidence.

Q & A

  • What is the main issue discussed in the video about Earth 2 Metaverse?

    -The main issue discussed is the numerous problems and potential intentional wrongdoings within the Earth 2 Metaverse platform, including withdrawal issues, regulatory violations, and a lack of transparency with its user community.

  • What was promised by Earth 2 that it failed to deliver?

    -Earth 2 was promised as a metaverse where users could own land and engage in various activities, but it turned out to be a 2D website where users could only buy pictures of land, similar to Google Earth.

  • What withdrawal issues did players face in Earth 2?

    -Players faced issues where they could no longer withdraw fiat currency from the game due to new regulations and the platform's own decisions to launch its crypto, violating these regulations.

  • What is the current status of fiat withdrawals in Earth 2?

    -As of the video, fiat withdrawals have been suspended indefinitely, and users are only allowed to withdraw in the form of the platform's own cryptocurrency, Essence, with a daily limit that affects all users collectively.

  • What was the community's reaction to the changes in withdrawal rules?

    -The community largely reacted negatively to the changes, viewing them as a 'rug pull' and expressing concerns about the platform's intentions and the legality of the new rules.

  • Why did Earth 2 remove the land income tax feature?

    -The exact reason for removing the land income tax feature was not disclosed by Earth 2, but it is speculated that it might be due to regulatory pressure and to avoid appearing like a Ponzi scheme.

  • What is the role of the cryptocurrency 'Essence' in Earth 2's current withdrawal system?

    -Essence is now the only method for users to withdraw their funds, as fiat currency withdrawals have been halted. Users can convert their in-game currency to Essence and then withdraw it, but this has been criticized for being potentially exploitative.

  • How has Earth 2 handled criticism and concerns from its community?

    -Earth 2 has been criticized for not adequately addressing concerns and even banning users, including a moderator named SE, who raised questions about the platform's operations and withdrawal system.

  • What prediction does the video creator make about Earth 2's future?

    -The video creator predicts that Earth 2 will face a catastrophic event within four months if the financial issues are as severe as they appear, potentially leading to the platform falling apart.

  • What was the issue with the new authentication system implemented by Earth 2?

    -The new authentication system was case-sensitive and caused a security flaw where users could log into other users' accounts with similar usernames, potentially allowing unauthorized access to personal information and transactions.

Outlines

00:00

🌎 Earth 2 Metaverse Issues

The script discusses the Earth 2 metaverse, which was marketed as a virtual space where users could invest in land but turned out to be a 2D website. The speaker reflects on the last month's issues, including withdrawal problems where players could no longer cash out their fiat currency due to new regulations. The company's attempt to launch its own cryptocurrency to bypass these regulations backfired, leading to further complications. The script also mentions an interview with CEO Shane Isaac about these issues, and the lack of resolution after two weeks of waiting.

05:01

🚫 Withdrawal System Critique

The speaker criticizes Earth 2's new withdrawal system, which they find unacceptable and possibly illegal. Fiat withdrawals have been suspended, and users are now offered to withdraw in the form of the company's own cryptocurrency, which the speaker finds 'scummy'. The community is upset because they were promised profits, which were partly generated through a now-defunct land income tax system. The speaker speculates that regulatory pressure may have led to the removal of this system, and there's a sense of betrayal as users are unable to cash out their earnings.

10:04

💰 Limited Crypto Withdrawals and Developer Concerns

The script continues to discuss the absurdity of the £5,000 daily limit for crypto withdrawals, which is not per person but a collective limit for all users. This has led to long cash-out times and suspicions that Earth 2 might not have the funds to repay users. The speaker also raises concerns about the company's integrity, citing cases where developers were let go without pay, and shares a public statement from a former senior game developer who claims Earth 2 has not fulfilled its payment obligations.

15:04

🔐 Authentication System Fiasco

The speaker describes a recent change in Earth 2's authentication system that led to a significant security breach. Users were able to log into other users' accounts due to a case sensitivity issue with the new system. This not only exposed personal information but also allowed unauthorized purchases. The situation was handled poorly by Earth 2, with no clear communication or resolution, adding to the growing list of controversies.

20:06

🐉 Nav Mesh Misrepresentation and Community Neglect

The script addresses Earth 2's claim of creating a 'revolutionary' technology called 'nav mesh', which is actually a standard feature in game development. The speaker criticizes this misrepresentation and the company's focus on superficial updates like skins and animals while ignoring more pressing issues. The removal of a well-liked moderator, SE, from the Discord community for questioning the company's actions further illustrates the deteriorating relationship between Earth 2 and its user base.

25:07

📉 Predicting Earth 2's Downfall

In the final paragraph, the speaker predicts that Earth 2 will face a catastrophic event within four months due to financial issues and a loss of user trust. They summarize the ongoing disasters, failures, and negligence, and express disappointment at the state of the metaverse project. The speaker thanks their patrons and signs off, reflecting the overall negative sentiment surrounding Earth 2.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Metaverse

The metaverse is a virtual reality space in which users can interact with a computer-generated environment and other users. In the context of the video, Earth 2 is described as a 'metaverse' where users can own land and engage in activities. However, the video criticizes Earth 2 for failing to live up to the metaverse concept, reducing it to a simple 2D website.

💡Sandbagging

In the video, 'sandbagging' is used to describe the intentional actions of Earth 2's management that led to the project's failure. It implies that rather than just experiencing unfortunate outcomes, there was a deliberate effort to make things go wrong, possibly to manipulate the situation for their own benefit.

💡Regulations

Regulations in this context refer to legal rules and policies that govern certain activities, such as cryptocurrency trading. The video discusses how Earth 2 faced issues with regulations, which led to problems with fiat currency withdrawals. It highlights a situation where the company seemed to intentionally violate new regulations to avoid paying out fiat currency.

💡Fiat Currency

Fiat currency is money that a government has declared to be legal tender, but it is not backed by a physical commodity like gold or silver. In the video, the issue of withdrawing fiat currency from the Earth 2 game is a central problem, with the company failing to allow users to cash out their earnings.

💡Cryptocurrency

Cryptocurrency is a digital or virtual currency that uses cryptography for security. The video mentions that Earth 2 decided to launch its own cryptocurrency, which led to regulatory issues and a shift from fiat currency to a digital asset that users could only withdraw under certain conditions.

💡Land Income Tax

In the Earth 2 game, 'Land Income Tax' was a feature where owning land would generate income from new players buying land nearby. This concept is criticized in the video as being similar to a Ponzi scheme, where early investors获利靠新投资者的资金, and it was later removed without explanation.

💡Ponzi Scheme

A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investing scam promising high rates of return with little risk to investors. The video suggests that the Land Income Tax feature in Earth 2 was borderline Ponzi scheme, as it relied on constant recruitment of new investors to pay the returns to earlier investors.

💡Rug Pull

A 'rug pull' in the context of cryptocurrency and online investments refers to an exploit where developers abandon a project and run away with the funds. The video uses this term to describe Earth 2's withdrawal system, implying that the company pulled the rug out from under its community by changing the rules and leaving them unable to withdraw their money.

💡Authentication System

An authentication system is a security measure that verifies the identity of users. The video discusses a change in Earth 2's authentication system that led to a significant security flaw, allowing users to log into other users' accounts, which is a severe breach of security and trust.

💡Data Breach

A data breach occurs when unauthorized individuals gain access to sensitive information. The video suggests that Earth 2's authentication system change resulted in a data breach, exposing user information to others, which is a serious violation of privacy and security.

💡Nepotism

Nepotism is the practice among those with power or influence of favoring relatives or friends, especially by giving them jobs. The video hints at nepotism within Earth 2's management, suggesting that decisions are made based on personal relationships rather than merit, which can lead to an unfair and inefficient operation.

Highlights

Earth 2 metaverse situation is chaotic and many issues have arisen in just a month.

Earth 2 promised a metaverse but turned out to be a 2D website for buying land tiles.

Players faced withdrawal issues as they could not cash out their fiat currency.

Earth 2's response to regulations was to launch their own crypto, violating the rules and halting fiat payouts.

The community was initially told that withdrawal issues would be resolved in a few days, but they persisted.

An update on withdrawal rules was released, but it was not favorable and involved converting earnings to their own cryptocurrency.

The land income tax feature, a primary profit source for users, was removed without explanation.

Users are limited to a £5,000 daily withdrawal cap in the form of Earth 2's cryptocurrency for everyone combined.

There are suspicions that Earth 2 may not have the funds to repay users.

Several developers have claimed they were let go by Earth 2 and not paid.

Authentication system changes led to a security catastrophe where users could access others' accounts.

Moderator SE was removed and banned from Earth 2's Discord for pointing out issues with the withdrawal system.

Earth 2's response to crises includes releasing new skins and discussing AI for animals instead of addressing financial issues.

Earth 2 claimed to have developed 'nav mesh' technology, which is actually a standard feature in game development.

Prediction: Earth 2 may face a catastrophic collapse within four months due to financial issues and loss of user trust.