Is Google's Imagen 3 BETTER than MidJourney? 🤔

Everyday AI
31 Jul 202413:07

TLDRIn this video, Jordan Wilson from Everyday AI explores Google's new AI image-generating model, Imagen 3, comparing it to MidJourney and DALL-E 3. He discusses the accessibility of the model and conducts a live comparison of image quality and prompt handling. Wilson is impressed with Imagen 3's performance, noting it may surpass MidJourney in quality and prompt accuracy, despite some inconsistencies. The video offers a hands-on look at these AI tools, sparking interest in the advancements in generative AI.

Takeaways

  • 🆕 Google has released a new AI image-generating model called Imagen 3.
  • 🔍 The video compares Imagen 3 with MidJourney and DALL-E 3 to see if it's better.
  • 📧 The host, Jordan Wilson, received an email about Imagen 3 and will show how to access it.
  • 🎨 Users need to sign up for Imagen 3 through Google's AI Test Kitchen to try it out.
  • 📸 The video does a live comparison of the AI models using the same prompts for each.
  • 🌇 The prompt used was 'realistic photo of the Chicago skyline at sunset with bright and vivid colors'.
  • 🖼️ Imagen 3 produced good quality images, above DALL-E's previous output but not quite at MidJourney's level.
  • 🖌️ Imagen 3 allows for editing, such as making the sky area more vivid and brighter.
  • 🤔 There's inconsistency in the outputs from Imagen 3, with varying levels of quality and prompt handling.
  • 📈 The video suggests that Imagen 3 might be better than MidJourney in some aspects, which was unexpected.
  • 🌳 For a more artistic prompt, Imagen 3 captured the essence of a 'giant treehouse village in a dense Bali jungle' quite well.

Q & A

  • What is the topic of the video?

    -The video discusses Google's new AI image generating model, Imagen 3, and compares it with MidJourney and DALL-E 3.

  • Who is the host of the video?

    -The host of the video is Jordan Wilson, who is also the host of Everyday AI.

  • What is Everyday AI?

    -Everyday AI is a daily live stream podcast and newsletter that helps everyday people learn and leverage generative AI.

  • How can viewers access Google's new AI image generator?

    -Viewers can access Google's new AI image generator by signing up to try Imagen 3 through Google's AI Test Kitchen.

  • What are the features of Imagen 3 discussed in the video?

    -The video discusses features such as best quality toggle, edit history, seed retrieval, and in-painting capabilities of Imagen 3.

  • How does the video compare Imagen 3 with DALL-E 3 and MidJourney?

    -The video compares Imagen 3 with DALL-E 3 and MidJourney by running the same prompts through each AI to see how the outputs compare in terms of quality and prompt handling.

  • What was the initial expectation of Imagen 3's performance compared to DALL-E 3 and MidJourney?

    -The host initially expected Imagen 3 to perform similarly to DALL-E 3 but was surprised to find that it might be better than MidJourney in terms of quality and prompt handling.

  • What are the editing capabilities of Imagen 3 mentioned in the video?

    -Imagen 3 allows users to copy, download, share, and flag the output. It also has an in-painting feature that allows users to edit specific areas of the generated image.

  • How does the video evaluate the quality of the AI-generated images?

    -The video evaluates the quality of the AI-generated images by comparing the realism, prompt handling, and overall aesthetic of the outputs from Imagen 3, DALL-E 3, and MidJourney.

  • What was the outcome of the head-to-head comparison between Imagen 3, DALL-E 3, and MidJourney?

    -The comparison showed that Imagen 3 performed better than expected, with outputs that were of higher quality and better prompt handling compared to DALL-E 3 and were potentially better than MidJourney.

  • What are some of the limitations or issues the host encountered while using Imagen 3?

    -The host encountered inconsistencies in the outputs from Imagen 3 and noted that it did not always handle prompts as well as DALL-E 3 and MidJourney, particularly regarding the vividness of colors.

Outlines

00:00

🚀 Introduction to Google's New AI Image Generator

The script introduces a new AI image generating model released by Google. The host, Jordan Wilson, expresses initial skepticism due to Google's past AI image generators' performance and controversies. He plans to demonstrate how to access Google's new AI image generator, called 'Imagine 3', and compares it with other models like Chat GPT's Dolly3 and Mid Journey. The host provides a step-by-step guide on signing up for Google's AI Test Kitchen to access Imagine 3 and shares his first impressions after using it. He also discusses the user interface and experience, noting Google's strengths in UI/UX design. The paragraph ends with a live comparison of the AI models using the same prompts to generate images.

05:00

🎨 Comparing AI Image Generation Models

This paragraph delves into a comparative analysis of Google's Imagine 3, Chat GPT's Dolly3, and Mid Journey. The host runs the same prompt through all three AI models to assess their output quality and prompt handling. He notes that Imagine 3 surpasses Dolly3 in quality, which he describes as generic and computer graphics-like, and is comparable to Mid Journey. The host also tests the editing features of Imagine 3, attempting to enhance the vividness of colors in the generated images. He finds that while Imagine 3's prompt handling isn't perfect, the quality of the images is impressive, especially when compared to Dolly3. The paragraph concludes with the host's surprise at Imagine 3's performance and his intention to conduct further tests and comparisons.

10:00

🌳 Artistic and Realistic Image Generation Test

The final paragraph focuses on testing the AI models' ability to generate artistic and realistic images. The host runs a series of prompts to generate images of people and a treehouse village, evaluating the models' consistency and prompt handling. He finds that Imagine 3 outperforms his expectations, producing high-quality images that are more photo-realistic than Dolly3's cartoon-like outputs. Mid Journey also performs well, but Imagine 3 shows a remarkable ability to handle natural language prompts effectively. The host concludes the video by expressing his surprise at Imagine 3's capabilities and invites viewers to subscribe for more content on AI tools. He also asks for feedback on the video and the new AI model's performance.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Imagen 3

Imagen 3 is Google's advanced AI image generation model. It is known for producing high-quality, realistic outputs, even for complex objects like hands [^2^]. The model is capable of following complex prompts accurately and offers features like inpainting and outpainting, which are useful for restoring or extending images [^3^]. It is built on a transformer-based architecture and benefits from Google's extensive computing resources, allowing it to generate detailed and realistic images [^3^].

💡MidJourney

MidJourney is an AI image generator that focuses on producing aesthetic and visually striking images. It may not always strictly adhere to the text input but is known for evoking emotion and wonder through its creations. MidJourney has a community-driven platform and is favored among digital artists for exploring creative possibilities [^3^]. It has also transitioned from a Discord-only interface to a more user-friendly web-based interface called MidJourney Alpha, enhancing usability and creativity [^4^].

💡AI image generators

AI image generators are tools that use artificial intelligence to create images based on textual descriptions or prompts. They have become popular for their ability to produce unique visuals and are used in various fields, including design, art, and content creation. The video discusses how Imagen 3 and MidJourney compare in terms of quality and adherence to prompts among other AI image generators [^2^].

💡Prompt handling

Prompt handling refers to an AI image generator's ability to accurately interpret and respond to textual prompts to create images. The video compares how well Imagen 3 and MidJourney handle prompts, with Imagen 3 showing a solid capability to integrate details into a coherent image, while MidJourney prioritizes aesthetic output over strict prompt adherence [^3^].

💡Inpainting

Inpainting is a feature of some AI image generators, including Imagen 3, that allows users to restore or fill in missing parts of an image. It is particularly useful for tasks like photo restoration, where parts of an image may be damaged or missing [^3^].

💡Outpainting

Outpainting is the ability to expand an image beyond its original borders by adding new elements smoothly. Imagen 3 introduces advanced outpainting features, providing flexibility for designers and artists to extend their work without starting from scratch [^3^].

💡Transformer-based architecture

Transformer-based architecture refers to the underlying technology used in AI models like Imagen 3 and DALL-E, which processes information using a transformer network. This architecture enables the model to handle large datasets and generate high-quality images [^3^].

💡Distributed computing

Distributed computing is a technique that allows the processing of large datasets across multiple computers, which is beneficial for AI models like Imagen 3. It enables efficient and fast image generation by leveraging Google's extensive computing resources [^3^].

💡User interface (UI)

User interface, or UI, refers to the design of the tools and controls presented to the user in a software application. The video praises Google's Imagen 3 for its intuitive UI, which is similar to Google Search, making it easy for users to navigate and generate images [^2^].

💡Batch processing

Batch processing is the ability to process multiple images at once, which saves time and increases efficiency. Imagen 3 supports batch processing, allowing users to work with multiple images simultaneously [^1^].

Highlights

Google has released a new AI image generating model called Imagen 3.

Imagen 3 is being compared to ChatGPT's DALL-E and MidJourney for image generation capabilities.

Google's previous AI image generators were not as good, and there was some controversy surrounding them.

The host, Jordan Wilson, will show how to access Google's new AI image generator and perform comparisons.

To try Imagen 3, users need to sign up for Image FX through Google's AI Test Kitchen.

Imagen 3 provides four generations of images, similar to MidJourney, and more than DALL-E's one generation.

The user interface and experience of Imagen 3 are praised for being user-friendly.

Imagen 3's output quality is compared to DALL-E and MidJourney, with initial results showing promise.

Imagen 3 did not replicate the Chicago skyline accurately, indicating room for improvement in prompt handling.

The video discusses the potential for Imagen 3 to improve, especially with better prompting and as the model develops.

Imagen 3 shows inconsistency in output, with varying levels of quality and prompt handling across different attempts.

MidJourney is noted for better prompt handling, especially in requests for bright and vivid colors.

Imagen 3 allows for editing of generated images, a feature also available in DALL-E.

The video demonstrates Imagen 3's ability to adjust image details based on user feedback, such as making the sky more vivid.

Imagen 3's performance in generating photorealistic images of people is compared to MidJourney, with impressive results.

The video concludes with a comparison of Imagen 3, DALL-E, and MidJourney for generating an artistic prompt of a treehouse village.

Imagen 3 shows potential to be better than MidJourney in certain aspects, surprising the host.

The video encourages viewers to subscribe and provide feedback on the comparison and potential future content.

Create Stunning Images & Videos in Seconds！

Explore the latest Flux 1.1 model and powerful Flux tools.

Create Stunning Images & Videos in Seconds！Try It Free