Why Agent Frameworks Will Fail (and what to use instead)

Dave Ebbelaar
27 Jun 202419:21

TLDRIn this video, Dave Abar, founder of Data Lumina, critiques agent frameworks for AI solutions, suggesting they are overly complex and not robust enough for most business automation needs. He advocates for a simpler approach, using data pipelines and design patterns like the chain of responsibility, which are more reliable and easier to understand. Abar demonstrates building a generative AI app with a clear input-processing-output flow, using Python as an example, and recommends avoiding complex frameworks in favor of first principles.

Takeaways

  • 🧐 Dave Abar, founder of Data Lumina, discusses his views on agent frameworks and their potential shortcomings.
  • 📈 Agentic workflows and frameworks have gained popularity with the rise of large language models.
  • 🔗 Frameworks like Autogen, Crew AI, and Lang Chain are built around chaining agents for reasoning and workflow management.
  • 🤖 These tools often involve complex agent interactions with goals, backstories, and tasks, which may exceed the needs of many real-world automation processes.
  • 🛠 Dave suggests that most business processes require clear, defined steps rather than the creativity that agent frameworks often introduce.
  • 🔄 He recommends a simpler approach, using data pipelines and first principles to build AI applications, avoiding unnecessary complexity.
  • 🔧 Data pipelines follow a structured input-processing-output model, which is more aligned with traditional ETL processes and less prone to errors.
  • 🔗 The chain of responsibility pattern can be effectively used to create a sequence of processing steps in AI applications.
  • 🔧 Dave demonstrates a Python project template for a generative AI system that uses a data pipeline approach to process emails and generate responses.
  • 🔄 The use of the Instructor Library is highlighted for validating outputs and reducing 'hallucinations' in AI-generated content.
  • 🔗 A sequential, directed acyclic graph (DAG) approach is advocated for building reliable AI systems, ensuring data flows in one direction without loops.

Q & A

  • What is the main argument of Dave Abar in the video titled 'Why Agent Frameworks Will Fail'?

    -Dave Abar argues that agent frameworks are likely to fail because they are too complex for most use cases and not robust enough. He suggests that for most business automation needs, simpler solutions based on data pipelines and first principles are more appropriate.

  • Who is Dave Abar and what is his background?

    -Dave Abar is the founder of Data Lumina, where he has been building custom data and AI solutions for the past 5 years. He also creates educational content to help others learn to do the same and start freelancing.

  • What is the core concept behind agent frameworks according to the video?

    -The core concept behind agent frameworks is to use language models as reasoning engines to determine a sequence of actions within a workflow, often involving chaining agents together that have specific goals, backstories, and tasks.

  • What are some examples of agent frameworks mentioned in the video?

    -Some examples of agent frameworks mentioned in the video are Autogen, Crew AI, and Lang Chain, which all provide ways to build agents with different levels of complexity and features.

  • Why does Dave Abar believe that most real-world processes do not require the creativity that agent frameworks offer?

    -Dave Abar believes that most real-world processes for business automation are clearly defined and require a straightforward sequence of steps rather than the creative problem-solving that agent frameworks are designed for.

  • What alternative approach does Dave Abar recommend instead of using agent frameworks?

    -Dave Abar recommends building applications from the ground up using a data pipeline approach, which is simpler, more structured, and follows a directed acyclic graph (DAG) design principle to ensure reliability.

  • How does Dave Abar describe the typical flow of applications built with large language models?

    -Dave Abar describes the typical flow of applications built with large language models as having inputs, a processing layer that may involve one or multiple LLM calls or external API calls, and an output which is typically generated by the model.

  • What is the 'chain of responsibility pattern' mentioned in the video and how is it used?

    -The 'chain of responsibility pattern' is a design pattern where a sequence of objects is responsible for fulfilling a request. In the context of the video, it is used to define sequential steps in a data pipeline, allowing for easy addition, removal, or modification of steps.

  • How does Dave Abar's approach to building AI applications differ from using agent frameworks?

    -Dave Abar's approach focuses on simplicity and clarity by building applications as data pipelines with sequential steps, avoiding the complexity and potential for 'hallucinations' that can come with agent frameworks. He emphasizes understanding the underlying processes and using proven design patterns.

  • What is the 'instructor Library' mentioned in the video and how does it relate to building AI applications?

    -The 'instructor Library' is a tool used to patch large language models and validate outputs by defining a response model. It is mentioned as a powerful way to change how applications are built around large language models by adding validation and reasoning capabilities.

Outlines

00:00

🤖 Agent Frameworks Critique and Alternatives

Dave Abar, founder of Data Lumina, introduces his skepticism towards agent frameworks for AI solutions. He believes these frameworks, which include tools like Autogen, Crew AI, and Langchain, are overly complex and not robust enough for most practical applications. Abar argues that these tools are based on chaining agents together for workflow automation, but real-world business processes often require clear definitions and straightforward automation steps. He suggests that using large language models (LLMs) directly for specific steps in a workflow is more effective than the agentic approach, which can lead to unpredictable outcomes due to its creative nature.

05:02

🧠 Simplifying AI Application Development

Abar recommends a simpler approach to building AI applications, focusing on first principles and clear, defined processes. He advises against relying on complex, abstracted frameworks that are still being developed and refined by the community. Instead, he suggests viewing AI applications as data pipelines, which have well-established principles and patterns. This approach involves a linear, directed acyclic graph (DAG) workflow, ensuring data flows in one direction without loops, which enhances system reliability. Abar emphasizes the importance of understanding the underlying processes and avoiding over-complication.

10:03

🔌 Practical Implementation of Data Pipelines

Dave Abar demonstrates the practical application of data pipelines in AI projects, using a Python project template as an example. The template is designed to handle incoming data, process it through defined steps, and output results, without the need for complex frameworks. He explains the use of design patterns like the chain of responsibility pattern to create a flexible, modular system where steps can be easily added or removed. Abar shows how to set up a pipeline for processing emails, using the Instruct library to classify the email and generate a response, while also incorporating reasoning and confidence scores to enhance output quality.

15:05

🔗 Conclusion and Freelancing Resources

In the final paragraph, Abar concludes by reiterating the benefits of a simple, data pipeline approach to AI application development. He also provides a resource for developers interested in freelancing, offering a video on how his company can help find clients. Abar encourages viewers to like the video and subscribe for more content, and he suggests watching a follow-up video for a deeper dive into building reliable systems with large language models using the Instruct library.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Agent Frameworks

Agent Frameworks refer to a set of tools or systems designed to create 'agents' that can perform tasks autonomously. In the context of the video, these frameworks like AutoGen, Crew AI, and LangChain are built around the concept of chaining agents to create workflows where each agent can reason and determine the next action. The video critiques these frameworks for being overly complex and not robust enough for many real-world automation tasks.

💡Large Language Models (LLMs)

Large Language Models are advanced AI systems capable of understanding and generating human-like text. They are central to the discussion in the video as they are used within Agent Frameworks to power agents' decision-making processes. The speaker suggests that while LLMs are powerful, they are often overused in frameworks, leading to unnecessary complexity.

💡Chaining Agents

Chaining agents is a process where multiple AI agents are linked together to perform a sequence of tasks. Each agent in the chain can make decisions based on the output of the previous one. The video argues that this approach, while creative, often results in complex and unreliable workflows that are not suitable for straightforward business processes.

💡Backstories, Roles, Goals

These terms are used to describe the attributes given to agents within Agent Frameworks. Each agent is assigned a backstory, role, and goals to guide its actions. The video suggests that these attributes, while adding a layer of complexity and creativity, are often unnecessary for the straightforward automation tasks that businesses typically seek.

💡Data Pipeline

A data pipeline is a system for processing and moving data from one place to another. In the video, the speaker advocates for using a data pipeline approach instead of Agent Frameworks for building AI solutions. This involves a linear sequence of steps for input, processing, and output, which is considered more reliable and easier to manage than agent-based workflows.

💡Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG)

A Directed Acyclic Graph is a data structure with one-way, non-repeating paths. The video suggests designing AI workflows as DAGs to ensure data flows in a predictable, one-way direction, which enhances the reliability of the system. This contrasts with the circular patterns often found in agentic workflows.

💡Chain of Responsibility Pattern

The Chain of Responsibility Pattern is a design pattern where a sequence of objects is given a chance to handle a request. In the video, it is used as an example of how to structure a data pipeline for AI applications, allowing for a clear, sequential processing of tasks without the need for complex agent interactions.

💡Penicillin Models

Penicillin Models refer to a method of using large language models to validate and guide the output of AI systems. The video mentions the use of the Instructor Library, which allows for the creation of Penicillin Models to ensure the reliability of AI-generated content.

💡Generative AI

Generative AI refers to AI systems that can create new content, such as text, images, or music. The video discusses building systems using Generative AI, particularly focusing on how to structure these systems for reliability and simplicity, rather than using complex Agent Frameworks.

💡Orchestration

Orchestration in the context of the video refers to the management and coordination of different AI agents within a framework to achieve a goal. The speaker criticizes the orchestration in Agent Frameworks for being overly complex and suggests a simpler, more direct approach to workflow management.

Highlights

Agent Frameworks are becoming popular with the rise of large language models.

Frameworks like Autogen, Crew AI, and Lang Chain allow building agents for workflows.

Most agent frameworks are too complex and not robust enough for many tasks.

Agents are typically chained together to reason and determine the next step in a workflow.

Crew AI allows designing agents with backstories, roles, goals, and tasks.

Real-world business processes often don't require creativity but defined steps.

Large language models are useful for solving specific steps in a process chain.

Generative AI applications usually follow an input-processing-output flow.

Agentic frameworks introduce a manager or orchestrator between agents.

Agentic workflows can involve complex interactions between multiple agents.

The speaker recommends avoiding complex frameworks for most business automation.

Simple, grounded approaches based on first principles are often more effective.

Data pipelines are a more established method for building applications.

Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) is a recommended approach for pipeline design.

Viewing AI problems as data pipelines simplifies the coding process.

The chain of responsibility pattern is useful for creating sequential processing steps.

The video provides an example of building a system to classify and reply to emails.

The use of the instructor Library is highlighted for validating model outputs.

The video concludes with a pitch for the speaker's company's services for freelancers.

The speaker suggests that understanding the problem and building from the ground up is key.