AI Art Webtoons are terrible. (I found another one)

BlackLightJack vs. Webtoon
12 Jan 202408:31

TLDRThe video discusses the reviewer's disappointment with an AI-art webtoon called Wolfbane, criticizing its inconsistent character design and lack of coherent storytelling. The reviewer argues that AI art should be used by skilled artists to enhance their work, not by beginners who may produce subpar content. They highlight the potential of AI in aiding artists, but express concern over its misuse by those who do not understand the creative process.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 The critic found another AI art webtoon, 'Wolfbane', which has a very low rating on the platform.
  • 👎 The webtoon is criticized for its poor quality, inconsistent character designs, and lack of a coherent narrative.
  • 🐺 The story features a group of anthropomorphic wolves in a medieval fantasy setting, fighting necromantic creatures.
  • 😡 The character designs are inconsistent, changing from panel to panel, which is distracting and detracts from the reading experience.
  • 🎭 The art style is compared to DeviantArt and middle school fanfiction, with the characters' appearances being highly generic.
  • 🖼️ The backgrounds and color compositions also change constantly, contributing to the jarring and disjointed feel of the webtoon.
  • 💬 The speech bubbles are criticized for their poor design, with opaque colors and default Comic Sans font that blends into the detailed backgrounds.
  • 📉 The reviewer initially had a neutral stance on AI art but was disappointed by the quality of this particular webtoon.
  • 🚫 The critic argues that only real artists should use AI art programs, as they can make productive and creative use of the technology.
  • 📚 The reviewer contrasts 'Wolfbane' with other webtoons like 'Africa', where the creators visibly improve their skills over time.
  • 👩‍🎨 The use of AI art by professional artists is seen as a tool to optimize workflow and alleviate the burden of creating content weekly.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video transcript?

    -The main topic of the video transcript is a critical review of an AI art webtoon called 'Wolfbane', which the speaker finds to be of very low quality.

  • What is the speaker's general opinion on AI art?

    -The speaker initially believed that AI art could be a useful tool for beginners to learn the foundations of art, but after reviewing 'Wolfbane', they feel that their previous opinion was wrong and that AI art in the wrong hands can produce subpar results.

  • What are some of the specific issues the speaker has with the characters in 'Wolfbane'?

    -The speaker points out that the characters in 'Wolfbane' have constantly changing designs, no discernable traits, and very inconsistent appearances from panel to panel, making it difficult to follow the story.

  • How does the speaker describe the art style of 'Wolfbane'?

    -The speaker describes the art style as inconsistent, with the character's facial features and the overall background changing from panel to panel, creating a jarring and distracting reading experience.

  • What is the speaker's issue with the paneling and composition of the webtoon?

    -The speaker criticizes the paneling and composition, stating that it feels like a random collection of AI-generated images rather than a cohesive narrative, with no clear connection between the images and the dialogue.

  • What does the speaker think about the use of AI art in the creation of comics?

    -The speaker believes that AI art should only be used by real artists to improve and optimize their workflow, not by those who are trying to create a story without understanding the basics of comic creation.

  • How does the speaker contrast 'Wolfbane' with another webtoon mentioned, 'Africa'?

    -The speaker contrasts 'Wolfbane' with 'Africa' by highlighting the clear improvement in the latter over time, showing that the creator is learning and developing their skills, unlike the creator of 'Wolfbane' who does not seem to be learning or improving.

  • What is the speaker's final verdict on 'Wolfbane'?

    -The speaker's final verdict is that 'Wolfbane' is a fundamentally flawed and nonsensical webtoon with no redeeming qualities, and they feel insulted by its existence.

  • What is the speaker's view on the appropriate use of AI art programs?

    -The speaker believes that only real artists should be allowed to use AI art programs to enhance their work and improve their productivity, rather than being used by those who lack artistic talent to create low-quality content.

  • Can you provide an example from the transcript where AI art was used effectively?

    -The speaker mentions a webtoon called 'Blood Ry' where AI art is used effectively to help the creators with certain tasks, such as drawing a bird on a character's shoulder, as a way to optimize their workflow.

  • What is the speaker's personal project related to the topic?

    -The speaker is working on a medieval fantasy furry comic of their own, and although they admit it may not look perfect, they take pride in the fact that they are creating it themselves rather than relying on AI-generated images.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Critique of AI-Generated Medieval Fantasy Comic

The speaker begins by discussing their experience with AI-generated art, particularly focusing on a medieval fantasy, furry webcomic called 'Wolfbane'. They express their dissatisfaction with the quality of the artwork, which they find to be of very low standard. The critique extends to the inconsistency of character design and the poor narrative structure of the comic. The speaker also mentions their previous experience reviewing AI art and their initial belief that AI could be a useful tool for beginners. However, they are proven wrong in this instance as the comic lacks coherence and displays a myriad of issues, from changing character appearances to jarring color schemes and backgrounds. The story, what little there is, is described as non-existent and a mess of storytelling, with the speaker advising that webcomic platforms should be a place for artists to improve their skills, not for the display of subpar AI-generated content.

05:00

🚫 The Misuse of AI Art and Its Impact on Creativity

In the second paragraph, the speaker delves deeper into their stance on the use of AI in art creation. They argue that only real artists should be allowed to use AI art programs, as they are the ones who can make productive and creative use of the technology. The speaker contrasts their own work on a medieval fantasy furry comic with the AI-generated 'Wolfbane', emphasizing the effort and skill involved in their creation process. They highlight the potential benefits of AI in assisting artists with their work, such as reducing the time-consuming aspects of drawing and allowing them to focus on improving their craft. However, the speaker is critical of those who misuse AI art to produce low-quality content without putting in the necessary effort to learn and grow as artists. The paragraph concludes with a call to support the speaker's content and a mention of their Patreon supporters.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI Art

AI Art refers to the creation of visual art using artificial intelligence. In the context of the video, the reviewer is critical of AI Art Webtoons, which are comics created with the assistance of AI. The reviewer suggests that AI Art lacks consistency and originality, as it is generated based on prompts, leading to a less authentic artistic product.

💡Webtoon

A Webtoon is a digital comic that is typically created and viewed online. It often features a vertical scroll format and can include interactive elements. In the video, the reviewer discusses the shortcomings of a specific Webtoon called 'Wolfbane', which uses AI Art for its visuals.

💡Character Design

Character design refers to the visual appearance and personality of the characters in a work of fiction. It includes aspects such as physical features, clothing, and accessories. The reviewer points out that 'Wolfbane' has inconsistent character designs, which change from panel to panel due to the use of AI Art.

💡Inconsistency

Inconsistency in a work of art or literature refers to the lack of uniformity or coherence in elements such as style, tone, or character portrayal. The video script highlights the inconsistency in the AI-generated art of 'Wolfbane', where characters and backgrounds change abruptly from one panel to the next, detracting from the overall quality and narrative of the Webtoon.

💡Paneling

Paneling in comics and Webtoons refers to the arrangement and layout of individual images or 'panels' on a page. It is a crucial aspect of visual storytelling that helps to guide the reader's eye and convey the flow of action. The reviewer criticizes the paneling in 'Wolfbane', stating that it feels haphazard and lacks a cohesive narrative structure.

💡Speech Bubbles

Speech bubbles are graphical elements in comics and Webtoons that contain the dialogue or thoughts of characters. They are an essential part of the storytelling medium, as they convey the audio component of the narrative. In the video, the reviewer finds the speech bubbles in 'Wolfbane' to be problematic due to their opaque and colored nature, which makes the text difficult to read against the detailed backgrounds.

💡Backgrounds

Backgrounds in visual storytelling, such as comics and Webtoons, provide context and setting for the characters and events. They help to create a sense of place and atmosphere. The video script criticizes the backgrounds in 'Wolfbane' for being overly detailed and inconsistently colored, which distracts from the main action and contributes to the overall chaotic feel of the Webtoon.

💡Storytelling

Storytelling is the craft of conveying events in a narrative form, which can be through spoken words, writing, or visual media like comics and Webtoons. Effective storytelling engages the audience and provides a clear and compelling narrative. The reviewer argues that 'Wolfbane' fails at storytelling, as the plot is non-existent and the use of AI Art results in a disjointed and incoherent narrative.

💡Artistic Expertise

Artistic expertise refers to the skill, knowledge, and experience an artist has in their field. It encompasses the ability to create original and high-quality works of art. The video suggests that AI Art can be a tool for beginners to learn the foundations of artistic expertise, but the reviewer ultimately believes that it cannot replace the creativity and skill of a human artist.

💡Training Ground

A training ground is a place or platform where individuals can practice and develop their skills. In the context of the video, the reviewer suggests that Webtoon canvas should be a training ground for new artists to hone their skills. However, they argue that this purpose is undermined when AI Art is used without understanding the principles of good comic creation.

💡Productive Use

Productive use refers to the effective and beneficial application of resources or tools. In the video, the reviewer argues that only real artists should be allowed to use AI art programs because they are the ones who can make productive and creative use of this medium. They believe that AI Art should be used to enhance an artist's workflow and improve upon their existing skills, rather than as a substitute for actual artistic creation.

Highlights

The reviewer expresses dissatisfaction with AI-generated art in webtoons.

The webtoon in question, 'Wolfbane', has one of the lowest rating scores on the platform.

The reviewer initially believed AI art could be a useful tool for beginners to learn artistic skills.

Inconsistencies in character design and art style are highlighted as major issues.

The story begins with generic and poorly defined characters.

The reviewer criticizes the constant changes in character appearances throughout the webtoon.

The art style's inconsistency is described as distracting and detrimental to the reading experience.

The webtoon's panel composition is criticized for lacking coherence and narrative structure.

The use of AI-generated images is compared to randomly generated prompts rather than a cohesive story.

The reviewer finds the dialogue and speech bubbles to be poorly executed and hard to read.

Backgrounds are criticized for having varying vibes and tones, disrupting the reading flow.

The story is described as non-existent and a mess of poor storytelling.

The reviewer contrasts 'Wolfbane' with a comic called 'Africa', showing improvement over time.

The reviewer argues that only real artists should use AI art programs for productive and creative purposes.

AI art is seen as a tool to optimize workflow and assist artists with time-consuming tasks.

The use of AI art by unskilled individuals results in fundamentally flawed and nonsensical works.

The reviewer emphasizes the importance of actual drawing skills in creating quality art.

The video ends with a call for support from Patreon sponsors.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now