How to spot AI Art scams so you don't waste your time and money

The Art Mentor
12 Jan 202313:25

TLDRThis video serves as an essential guide for art clients to identify AI-generated art and avoid scams. It highlights the importance of working with real artists who can bring specific visions to life, rather than AI which can only offer generic results. The guide points out red flags such as suspiciously low prices, lack of specificity in AI-generated work, and the use of common AI-related hashtags. It also advises checking the artist's profile history and consistency in style to ensure authenticity.

Takeaways

  • 🚫 AI art users are prevalent on social media, making it difficult to distinguish between genuine artists and AI-generated art.
  • 💡 Art clients deserve to work with artists who can bring their specific ideas and details to life, something AI cannot fully achieve.
  • 💰 AI users often offer commissions at extremely low prices, which can be a red flag for compromised quality and specificity.
  • 🔍 Check for descriptions asking for detailed prompts, indicating the use of AI which requires such input to function.
  • 🏷️ AI users tend to use the same hashtags like 'AI', 'mid-journey', or 'stable diffusion', signaling a lack of personal artistry.
  • 🛠️ AI-generated art often lacks consistency in style and quality, which can be a sign of AI use rather than a human artist's work.
  • 👀 Profiles with an unusually high number of artworks in a short period of time may indicate AI use rather than human creation.
  • 🎨 AI-generated art may have peculiar characteristics like hard edges, unrealistic anatomy, or surreal elements that lack coherence.
  • 🤔 Profiles claiming to be art directors or having 'AI' in their name are likely not real artists but AI users.
  • 🌐 AI users often have sketchy profiles with inconsistencies or claims that don't hold up to scrutiny.
  • 🔑 Art clients should be aware of the red flags to ensure they receive a personalized and high-quality commission experience.

Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the video?

    -The main purpose of the video is to provide an Ultimate Guide to help art clients identify AI-generated art and avoid scams, ensuring they get the quality and value they deserve from their commissioned projects.

  • Why should art clients avoid AI-generated art?

    -Art clients should avoid AI-generated art because it often lacks the specificity and personal touches that come with human-created art. AI can only produce compromises between what the client wants and what the machine allows, which may not meet the client's exact vision.

  • What are some red flags indicating an AI user's commission shop on social media platforms like deviantART?

    -Red flags include extremely low prices, requests for detailed descriptions from clients to feed the AI, and the use of common AI-related hashtags in their posts.

  • How can the descriptions of AI users' commission shops mislead clients?

    -The descriptions may imply that the AI can create breathtaking character designs in any style for very low prices, which can be misleading as the AI is not capable of producing truly unique and specific art as a human artist would.

  • What commonalities should clients look for in the hashtags used by AI users on social media?

    -Clients should look for hashtags such as 'AI', 'mid-journey', 'stable diffusion', and 'AI community', which are often used by AI users to flag their content as AI-generated.

  • Why might an AI user's profile on social media raise suspicions?

    -A suspicious profile might show an unusually high number of artworks for a short period of time on the platform, sketchy or unrealistic claims about the user's background, or inconsistencies in the style and quality of the artwork.

  • How can the titles and descriptions of artworks reveal if they are AI-generated?

    -If the titles or descriptions explicitly state that the artwork is AI-generated, or if they lack detail and seem generic or jumbled, it's likely that the artwork is not created by a human artist.

  • What is a major red flag when assessing an artist's profile on social media?

    -A major red flag is the presence of a high volume of artwork posted within a very short time frame, especially if the artist has only been active on the platform for a few months.

  • How can the naming conventions of artworks indicate AI-generated content?

    -If the titles contain 'AI' in them or seem random and nonsensical, it could indicate that the artwork is AI-generated, as AI users often do not put the same care into titling as human artists.

  • What are some visual indicators that a piece of artwork might be AI-generated?

    -Visual indicators include unrealistic or inconsistent anatomy, hard edges where soft edges should be, and a lack of coherence or reason in the composition, especially in surreal or abstract pieces.

  • How has the anime art scene been affected by AI-generated art?

    -The anime art scene has been heavily impacted by AI, with many AI-generated pieces exhibiting diffused edges and a cell-shaded appearance, which can be a red flag for discerning clients.

Outlines

00:00

🧐 Spotting AI Users in Art Commissions

This paragraph emphasizes the importance for art clients to discern between AI users and human artists when seeking commissions. It outlines the unique value clients receive from working with human artists, who can provide exact replicas of their ideas with specific details. The speaker warns against the compromises inherent in AI-generated art and urges clients to watch the entire video for tips on identifying AI users, such as their prevalence on social media and the tell-tale signs in their commission shops and hashtags.

05:01

🚩 Red Flags for Identifying AI Users in Art

The second paragraph delves into specific indicators that suggest an art provider might be an AI user rather than a human artist. It highlights the unusually high volume of artwork produced in a short time, suspiciously low prices, and the use of generic hashtags like 'AI', 'mid-journey', and 'stable diffusion'. The paragraph also points out inconsistencies in the quality and style of artwork, as well as the lack of a clear progression that would be expected from a human artist, as signs of AI involvement.

10:02

🎨 Distinctive Flaws in AI-Generated Art

The final paragraph discusses the distinctive flaws often found in AI-generated artwork, such as hard edges, surrealistic elements that lack coherence, and anatomical inaccuracies, particularly with hands and feet. It also addresses the impact of AI on the anime art scene, noting the typical soft, diffused edges that result from AI's struggle to render different levels of detail. The speaker encourages clients to seek the best commission experience and to be wary of the AI community's reputation for being 'nasty and toxic'.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI Art

AI Art refers to artworks created or influenced by artificial intelligence. In the context of the video, AI Art is a central theme as it discusses the prevalence of AI-generated art on social media platforms and how it can be distinguished from art created by human artists. The video aims to educate viewers on how to spot AI Art to avoid scams and ensure they receive the quality and originality they expect from commissioned art pieces.

💡Commissions

Commissions in the art world refer to works of art that are created upon the request and to the specifications of a client. The video emphasizes the importance of commissions for clients who have specific ideas they want to be realized in their artwork. It points out that AI users may not be able to meet the exacting standards of personalized commissions due to limitations in AI's creative capabilities.

💡Red Flags

Red flags are warning signs that something may not be as it appears or could be problematic. In the video, red flags are used to describe indicators that suggest an artist might be using AI to create art, which could compromise the uniqueness and specificity of a commissioned piece. Examples from the script include unusually cheap prices, generic hashtags, and a lack of consistency in an artist's portfolio.

💡DeviantART

DeviantART is an online community and platform where artists can showcase their work and offer commissions. The video mentions DeviantART as one of the platforms where AI users are particularly prevalent, using it as an example to illustrate how to identify AI-generated art among the community of artists.

💡AI Users

AI Users in the script refers to individuals who utilize artificial intelligence to create art, often for commercial purposes such as selling prints or offering commissions. The video discusses the distinction between AI Users and traditional artists, highlighting the potential lack of originality and personal touch in AI-generated works.

💡Specificity

Specificity in the context of the video refers to the detailed and unique requirements that a client might have for their commissioned artwork. It is mentioned as a key aspect that AI-generated art may fail to capture due to the limitations of AI in understanding and executing complex and personalized creative visions.

💡Art Directors

An Art Director is a professional who oversees the visual style and images in various types of media. The video uses the term to highlight a potential red flag where AI Users might falsely claim to have prestigious titles to lend credibility to their work, which may not be genuine given the rapid production of art pieces that AI allows.

💡Anime

Anime refers to a style of animation that originated in Japan and has since become popular worldwide. The video points out that the anime style has been particularly affected by AI Art, with AI-generated anime often characterized by diffused edges and a lack of the distinct features that characterize hand-drawn anime.

💡Consistency

Consistency in an artist's portfolio refers to a uniformity in style, technique, or subject matter that reflects the artist's personal touch and development over time. The video suggests that a lack of consistency can be a red flag for AI-generated art, as AI Users may produce works that lack a cohesive artistic vision.

💡Toxic Community

The term 'toxic community' in the video refers to the negative environment that can arise among AI Users, which may include dishonest practices and a lack of respect for the originality and effort involved in traditional art creation. It serves as a caution for clients to be aware of the potential ethical implications of choosing to work with AI Users.

Highlights

The video provides an Ultimate Guide to spotting AI users in the art industry to avoid scams and ensure quality in commissioned projects.

Art clients deserve to work with artists who can provide exact replicas of their ideas, which AI cannot guarantee.

AI-generated art often compromises on the specifics of a client's vision due to its limitations.

A major red flag is AI users opening commission shops with prices that are suspiciously cheap.

AI users often require clients to provide detailed descriptions for AI to work with, which is not the role of a client.

AI users tend to use the same hashtags like 'AI', 'mid-journey', or 'stable diffusion', indicating a lack of original artwork.

Art platforms like ArtStation have started to include AI software names in their listings, helping to identify AI-generated works.

AI-generated art often lacks consistency in style and quality, which is a clear indicator of non-human creation.

AI users may falsely claim to be art directors or hold high positions in the art industry, which can be easily debunked.

A sudden influx of artworks on a profile within a short period is a red flag for AI-generated content.

AI-generated anime art often has diffused edges and a cell-shaded appearance due to AI's limitations in edge differentiation.

AI art tends to have hard edges and lacks the softness and natural progression seen in human artwork.

Surrealistic and abstract AI art often lacks coherence and logical structure, making it easily distinguishable from human art.

AI-generated art may have titles that include 'AI' or be nonsensical, indicating a lack of personal touch from an artist.

Anime scenes and NSFW content are particularly susceptible to AI art generation, with telltale signs of AI involvement.

The community around AI art can be toxic, and clients should be aware before deciding to work with AI users.

Art clients and artists should seek genuine collaboration and avoid the pitfalls of AI-generated art to ensure a quality experience.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now