illustrator gives tips on how to tell if art is AI generated
TLDRIn this insightful video, artist Patrick, also known as Veno, discusses the辨别 AI-generated art from human-created art. He shares his extensive experience in digital painting and outlines key indicators to look for, such as the high volume of output, lack of understanding of human anatomy and repetitive, meaningless details. Patrick emphasizes the importance of supporting real artists and their creative process, expressing concern that AI art could undermine the value and legitimacy of human-made artwork.
Takeaways
- 🎨 High Volume of Output: AI artists tend to produce and post a large volume of artwork at a rapid pace, much more than a human artist could create in the same time frame.
- 🔍 Inconsistency in Detail: AI-generated art often shows inconsistencies in the level of detail, with some areas being overly detailed and others lacking coherence or purpose.
- 🤖 AI Spew: AI-generated images may contain elements that appear detailed but dissolve into a chaotic mix of noise and odd shapes upon closer inspection.
- 🗡️ Misrepresentation of Objects: AI-generated art may struggle with accurately representing common objects, such as swords or boots, often resulting in unrealistic or distorted depictions.
- 🔄 Repetitive Patterns: AI art can exhibit repetitive patterns and details, lacking the intentional variation and creativity of human artists.
- 👤 Character Rendering: AI often struggles with rendering characters in a believable and stylistically consistent manner, leading to flat or unrealistic portrayals.
- 🌟 Lack of Artistic Intent: AI-generated images may lack a clear artistic vision or message, often appearing as mere collections of elements without a unifying theme or narrative.
- 💃 Common Subject Matter: AI art frequently focuses on certain subject matters, such as exaggerated depictions of women or generic sci-fi characters, reflecting the prompts and data it was trained on.
- 🔑 Identifying AI Art: Checking an artist's profile and output history can be a key indicator of whether the work is AI-generated, as human artists develop a consistent style and body of work over time.
- 🎭 Preservation of Artistic Value: The speaker expresses concern that the proliferation of AI art may diminish the appreciation and legitimacy of human-created art, as it can be seen as soulless and mass-produced.
Q & A
How long has Patrick, also known as Veno, been studying art?
-Patrick has been studying art for a significant amount of time, almost seven years, with a particular focus on digital painting which he started during his sophomore year of college, amounting to roughly four or five years of experience in that specific field.
What is Patrick's main concern about AI-generated art?
-Patrick's primary concern is the confusion and misattribution of AI-generated art as 'real' art. He is frustrated to see people online not distinguishing between human-created art and AI-generated pieces, which he believes undermines the value and effort of human artists.
What is the first characteristic Patrick mentions to identify an AI artist?
-The first characteristic Patrick mentions is the high volume of output. AI artists tend to post a large number of artworks, something that would typically take a human artist weeks or months to complete, on a daily or weekly basis.
What does Patrick refer to as 'AI spew'?
-'AI spew' is a term Patrick uses to describe the disorganized and noisy details often found in AI-generated art. It refers to elements that, upon close inspection, dissolve into a chaotic and unstructured mess of details, lacking the intentionality and coherence of human artistry.
How does Patrick differentiate between AI-generated art and human-created art in terms of detail?
-Patrick notes that AI-generated art often over-details and struggles with repetitiveness. Human artists, on the other hand, have an understanding of the subject matter and intent behind their work, leading to a more coherent and purposeful use of detail.
What is the significance of an AI artist's subject matter according to Patrick?
-Patrick points out that AI artists tend to favor certain subject matters, such as 'booby' women, rebels, and generic Sci-Fi or fantasy themes. These subjects often lack depth or a specific narrative, reflecting the AI's inability to generate substance beyond the surface level of an idea.
How does Patrick suggest one can identify mixed media usage in AI art?
-Patrick suggests that mixed media usage in AI art can be identified by a jarring and inconsistent blend of styles within the same piece. For example, a part of the artwork may have a very painterly, brushy style, while another part is rendered in a photo-realistic manner with no visible brush strokes.
What is Patrick's view on the impact of AI art on the art world?
-Patrick believes that the proliferation of AI art could lead to a devaluation of human artistry and a lack of respect for the hard work and passion that goes into creating real art. He fears that the legitimacy of artwork created by highly skilled and passionate human artists might be doubted due to the easy and soulless production of AI art.
How does Patrick demonstrate the evolution of his own art?
-Patrick demonstrates the evolution of his art by showing a progression of his work on his Instagram account, which includes his first digital painting and various styles and subjects he has explored over the years. This showcases the growth, consistency, and unique style of a human artist committed to their craft.
What is the main advice Patrick gives to discern AI art from human art?
-Patrick's main advice is to examine the artist's profile and the volume and consistency of their work. AI artists typically produce a high volume of work that lacks the depth and coherence of human-made art, which becomes evident when looking at their overall output.
How does Patrick feel about the creators of AI art?
-Patrick feels that many AI art creators are disinterested in the culture and vision of art. He believes they are often scared of trying and failing at creating something themselves, leading to the production of derivative and soulless AI art that lacks the passion and creativity of human artists.
Outlines
🎨 Identifying AI Art Through Volume and Style
Patrick, also known as Veno, an experienced digital artist, discusses methods to discern AI-generated art from human-created art. He emphasizes the high volume of AI art output, as AI can produce a vast amount of work in a short time, which would typically take a human artist much longer. He also points out the 'AI spew' phenomenon, where AI-generated images have excessive and mismatched details, especially in decorative elements like sword handles. The lack of understanding of human artistry is evident in the odd and uncharacteristic renderings of common objects.
🖌️ Distinguishing AI Art by Style and Detail
Patrick continues his analysis by highlighting the inconsistent styles and details in AI art, such as the abrupt shift from painterly to photorealistic renderings. He points out that AI often struggles with understanding the purpose and functionality of objects, leading to unrealistic and repetitive details. The talk also touches on the common themes in AI art, like overly sexualized women or generic sci-fi characters, which lack depth and substance, reflecting the lack of a creative vision behind them.
👤 The Impact of AI on Art and Artists
In the final paragraph, Patrick expresses his concerns about the impact of AI art on the art community and culture. He worries that the ease with which AI generates images might lead to a devaluation of human artistic efforts and a lack of respect for the skill and dedication of real artists. He argues that AI art, often created by individuals who are disinterested in the arts, can feel soulless and derivative, potentially undermining the legitimacy and value of original artwork created by passionate artists.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Digital Painting
💡AI Art
💡Output Volume
💡AI Spew
💡Artistic Intent
💡Mixed Media
💡Repetitive Detail
💡Subject Matter
💡Style Consistency
💡Artistic Process
💡Legitimacy of Artwork
Highlights
Patrick, also known as Veno, is an artist with seven years of experience in studying digital painting and art.
Veno started digital painting during his sophomore year in college, which was around five years ago.
The frustration with online discussions about AI-generated art versus human-made art led Veno to share his methods for identifying AI art.
A key characteristic of AI artists is the high volume of artwork they produce, often posting pieces that would take human artists weeks or months to complete.
AI-generated art often features 'AI spew,' where the artwork has a noisy, unsymmetrical, and odd organic appearance, especially in the details.
AI-generated art may have a suggestion of a subject but lacks depth and understanding of the subject matter, leading to a 'dissolving' effect upon closer inspection.
AI-generated art tends to over-detail and render lines and folds in an unrealistic manner, not understanding the natural contours and form of objects.
AI-generated art often repeats patterns and details excessively, showing a lack of intention or understanding of the subject.
Mixed media usage is not an indication of AI art; it's the lack of understanding and the odd rendering of subjects that can be a sign.
AI-generated art often features a blend of styles that don't make sense together, creating a jarring effect.
AI-generated art struggles with rendering repetitive details, often leading to aimless and meaningless patterns.
AI-generated art tends to focus on popular and superficial subjects, such as 'booby' women or generic sci-fi characters.
Veno emphasizes the importance of checking an artist's profile and their body of work to understand the context and legitimacy of their art.
Veno shares his own art journey and development over the years, showcasing the consistency and growth in his style.
Veno expresses concern that AI art may lead to a devaluation of human-made art and a lack of respect for the hard work and passion of artists.
The lasting impact of AI art may be the doubt and skepticism it creates around the authenticity and value of real artwork.
Veno argues that AI art lacks the soul and passion behind human-created art, as it is often produced by individuals who are disinterested in the culture and vision of art.
Veno's video serves as a guide to help viewers differentiate between AI-generated art and the work of dedicated, passionate artists.
