🔥 Did I Rank With HarborSEO? Tried and Tested..

WordsAtScale
10 Sept 202409:22

TLDRIn this video, Vlad reviews HarborSEO, comparing it to other AI writing tools. He discusses its ranking performance, output quality, and features like infographics and keyword research. HarborSEO currently ranks 6th among AI writers, but Vlad points out ongoing technical issues. Despite these, he shares a successful ranking for an article generated using HarborSEO, though he stresses that rankings aren't the sole measure of an AI writer's effectiveness. He offers insights on usability and updates, encouraging viewers to explore the tool for themselves.

Takeaways

  • 🔥 Harbor SEO is currently ranked 6th among popular AI writers based on performance.
  • 🤖 The tool is still under development, with continuous updates being rolled out.
  • 🔧 Harbor SEO offers unique features like infographics generation but lacks strong SEO optimization capabilities.
  • 📊 The tool scored a 49 in SEO, with readability at grade 10, which was improved to grade 7 after some edits.
  • 💻 Harbor SEO has some technical issues, like broken internal links and missing diagrams when saving content.
  • 🧠 The content generated by Harbor SEO is around 85% AI-generated based on human content detection tools.
  • 🏆 The AI writer produced a passable article, with a quality score of 3 out of 5.
  • 📈 The article 'AI humanizer tools for academic writing' ranked 3rd on Google, suggesting some success in SEO ranking.
  • 📉 Rankings depend more on niche and SEO strategy rather than just the AI writer used.
  • 📝 The reviewer notes that while Harbor SEO has potential, it still needs significant improvements for consistency and reliability.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video?

    -The main topic of the video is a review and testing of HarborSEO, an AI writer tool, including its ranking among other AI writers, output quality, and the reviewer's personal experience with the tool.

  • Who is the presenter of the video?

    -The presenter of the video is Vlad, who describes himself as someone who learns fast and shares what works for him and his observations.

  • What is Vlad's profession or area of expertise?

    -Vlad is not explicitly described as an SEO Guru or the owner of a multi-million dollar business, but rather as someone who shares his learnings and experiences with AI writing tools.

  • What is Writer was AI?

    -Writer was AI is an AI writer exclusive directory launched by Vlad, where users can filter AI writers based on specific features such as humanized tax options or the ability to produce infographics.

  • What is Harbor SEO's current ranking among other AI writers?

    -According to the video, Harbor SEO is currently occupying the sixth spot in the ranking among other AI writers.

  • What is the SEO score of an article generated by Harbor SEO?

    -The article generated by Harbor SEO has an SEO score of 49, which improved to 55.4 after the H1 title was changed.

  • What is the readability grade of the article generated by Harbor SEO?

    -The readability grade of the article generated by Harbor SEO is grade 10, but it was grade 7 before the title was changed.

  • What is the action score of Harbor SEO's article?

    -The action score of Harbor SEO's article is one of the highest, indicating a high percentage of human-like content.

  • What are the issues Vlad faced while using Harbor SEO?

    -Vlad faced technical issues with Harbor SEO, such as internal links pointing to non-existent articles and diagrams or infographics not showing up when pasted into HTML.

  • What is Vlad's opinion on the effectiveness of AI writers based on rankings?

    -Vlad believes that ranking is not proof enough that an AI writer works, as he had success with different AI writers in the past, and it's more about retaining the rankings rather than just achieving them.

  • Was Vlad able to rank with Harbor SEO?

    -Yes, Vlad was able to rank with Harbor SEO, as evidenced by one of his recent articles on 'AI humanizer tools for academic writing' which ranked third in search results.

Outlines

00:00

🔍 Overview and Introduction to Harbor SEO

In this introductory segment, Vlad welcomes viewers to his video, where he plans to review and rank Harbor SEO in comparison to seven other popular AI writers. He shares that the video will focus on output quality, personal impressions, and whether Harbor SEO helps in ranking content. Vlad clarifies that he’s not an SEO expert or a large-scale business owner but simply someone who learns quickly and shares his experiences. He also mentions his AI writer directory, which allows users to filter based on specific features such as humanized text or infographic creation, with Harbor SEO being a newer tool featured in this directory.

05:02

📊 Harbor SEO’s Performance and Ranking

This section details the current ranking of Harbor SEO, where Vlad objectively ranks it as sixth among the tools. He emphasizes that this ranking is not influenced by bias. He discusses its performance, highlighting that while Harbor SEO is still in development, it has unique features but lacks certain capabilities compared to others, like one-click SEO optimization. Its readability score is passable (grade 10), and it scores moderately well in terms of human-like output, at 15%. Vlad provides insight into how these rankings are calculated, based on SEO scores, user reviews, and technical features.

⚙️ Technical Issues and Limitations of Harbor SEO

Vlad shares his personal challenges with Harbor SEO, discussing technical issues he has encountered, such as broken internal links and difficulties in preserving HTML formatting when pasting content. He acknowledges that while the tool is a work in progress, these issues are frequent, though they don't impact the overall ranking in his directory. He stresses that his rankings are based on a defined calculation, independent of his personal experience or control over how the scores are generated.

📈 The Role of Rankings and SEO Performance

Here, Vlad questions the validity of ranking as a sole measure of an AI writer’s effectiveness. He draws from his experience using tools like GPT-4 and Agility Writer, which helped him achieve rankings for content in as little as a few hours. However, he emphasizes that maintaining rankings is more important than just achieving them. He explains how his latest article, created with Harbor SEO on the topic of AI humanizer tools, ranked well on the third spot. This ranking was based on a keyword suggested by Harbor SEO's research features, which he finds useful.

🛠️ Analyzing the Article Generation Process with Harbor SEO

In this paragraph, Vlad delves into the article creation process using Harbor SEO. He highlights the content structure, mentioning a concise introduction, internal links, and visual aids such as diagrams and tables. However, he also points out a critical error where a tool was mentioned twice, illustrating the potential for inaccuracies in the tool's output. Vlad compares the performance of Harbor SEO with other AI tools, concluding that one article ranked while another did not. He suggests that evaluating an AI writer’s quality should involve testing multiple niches with standardized conditions.

🔗 Final Thoughts and Recommendations on Harbor SEO

In his closing thoughts, Vlad offers a summary of his experience with Harbor SEO, stating that despite some technical shortcomings, it performs reasonably well, especially in niche tasks like creating infographics and performing keyword research. He encourages viewers to explore the tool, read his full review, and subscribe to his newsletter for additional resources. Vlad expresses gratitude to his audience and signs off, leaving viewers with a positive but realistic impression of Harbor SEO.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Harbor SEO

Harbor SEO is an AI writing tool focused on creating SEO-optimized content. It ranks lower in comparison to other AI writers due to missing features like inbuilt SEO optimization.

💡Ranking

Ranking refers to a website's position on search engine results pages. In the context of the video, Harbor SEO's performance is evaluated by its ability to rank content.

💡AI Writer

AI Writers are tools that use artificial intelligence to generate written content. The video discusses several AI writers, including Harbor SEO, that are used for creating SEO-optimized articles.

💡SEO Score

The SEO score indicates how well-optimized content is for search engines. Harbor SEO had a score of 49, suggesting improvements are needed in its optimization features.

💡Readability

Readability measures how easy it is to read the text. Harbor SEO's content readability fluctuated between grade 7 and grade 10, influencing the content’s appeal and usability.

💡Zero GBD Score

Zero GBD Score evaluates how much of the content appears human-written versus AI-generated. Harbor SEO's content had a lower humanization score, reflecting its AI-generated nature.

💡Infographics

Infographics are visual representations of information. Harbor SEO is highlighted as one of the few tools capable of producing infographics, despite some issues when saving and embedding them.

💡Internal Links

Internal links are hyperlinks that lead to other pages on the same website. The video mentioned issues with Harbor SEO's internal linking feature, which sometimes linked to non-existent articles.

💡Keyword Research

Keyword research is the process of finding and analyzing search terms people use in search engines. Harbor SEO offers keyword research features that help users find relevant terms for their content.

💡Humanizer Tools

Humanizer tools modify AI-generated text to make it sound more human. The video discusses using these tools to improve content quality, particularly in the academic writing niche.

Highlights

Introduction to the review of Harbor SEO and the focus on testing and ranking.

Overview of the performance of Harbor SEO among other AI writers, currently ranking sixth.

Mention of the user’s experience and the challenges faced with Harbor SEO, emphasizing the tool's work-in-progress status.

Discussion of the SEO score of Harbor SEO, which is 49 due to limited SEO optimization capabilities.

Harbor SEO’s readability score of grade 10, indicating passable readability.

Highlight of Harbor SEO’s high action score, with a focus on human-like content generation.

Comparison of Harbor SEO’s human content generation percentage with other tools, showing only 15% human-like content.

Quality score of Harbor SEO, which is measured at 3 out of 5.

Example of content generated by Harbor SEO, including a short introduction, internal links, and a table in HTML.

Reevaluation of the SEO score after modifying the H1 title, showing an improved score.

Challenges with Harbor SEO, such as issues with internal links and infographics not displaying correctly.

Clarification that the ranking of Harbor SEO was not affected by personal bias, emphasizing objectivity.

Statement on the user’s belief that ranking alone is not proof of an AI writer’s effectiveness.

Example of a successful ranking article created with Harbor SEO, showcasing its potential.

Final thoughts on Harbor SEO as a promising tool despite its technical issues, with a recommendation to check it out.