🛡NIGHTSHADE PROTECTION HAS AI BROS BIG MAD🤬 #procreate #aiart #stablediffusion #nightshadeai #glaze

Friendly Neighborhood Artist
24 Oct 202306:13

TLDRThe video discusses the controversy surrounding Nightshade, a tool developed by the creators of Glaze that aims to protect artists' work from being used by AI models without permission. The artist expresses concerns about the potential ugliness of the 'poisoning' effect on their artwork, but also hopes that Nightshade will be effective against AI art generators. They note the anger of professional artists towards the use of AI in art creation and the debate over the ethical use of technology. The artist also mentions the shift from NFTs to AI art and the desire for a balance where AI cannot exploit artists' work.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 An artist discusses Nightshade, a project by the creators of Glaze, which aims to protect artwork from AI models by confusing them.
  • 💧 Nightshade is believed to work on models based on CLIP, like Stable Diffusion, which is popular due to its privacy features.
  • 🤔 The artist expresses uncertainty about whether Nightshade will affect other AI models since their underlying code is not open source.
  • 😠 Professionals in the field are upset by Nightshade, as it could hinder their ability to create and use AI models.
  • 🚫 The artist has concerns about Nightshade potentially adding unattractive artifacts to artwork, which could deter its use.
  • 🌐 The artist has used Glaze on their work and found it left undesirable effects, questioning if Nightshade would do the same.
  • 📈 There's a debate between those who see Nightshade as a Luddite approach and those who view it as a necessary ethical response to technology.
  • 💬 The artist suggests that the discourse around Nightshade could lead to professionals moving on to other areas, allowing artists' spaces to be respected.
  • 👥 There's a tension between tech professionals and artists, with the latter wanting ethical use of AI that respects their work.
  • 📉 The artist notes a shift from NFTs to AI art, with some trying to sell AI-generated work at the cost of hiring a real artist, which they find questionable.
  • 📈 The artist hopes for a future where AI cannot commandeer artwork for profit, and where Nightshade or similar tools can help protect original creations.

Q & A

  • What is Nightshade and how does it relate to Glaze?

    -Nightshade is a project similar to Glaze, both developed by the same team. It's designed to disrupt AI models like Stable Diffusion by confusing them about the data they process, potentially protecting artists' copyrights.

  • Why are some people opposed to projects like Nightshade?

    -Some individuals, referred to in the transcript as 'AI bros' or 'pros', are upset about Nightshade because it challenges the functionality of AI models that they use, possibly hindering their ability to generate art based on existing works without consent.

  • What is the main concern of artists regarding AI-generated art, according to the script?

    -Artists are concerned about the ethical implications of AI art generation, specifically how these technologies often do not consider artists' rights and may exploit their original works without permission.

  • What is the role of Stable Diffusion in relation to Nightshade?

    -Stable Diffusion is a popular AI model mentioned in the script that can be privately operated. Nightshade is expected to effectively disrupt models based on CLIP, like Stable Diffusion, but its impact on other AI generators remains uncertain.

  • Why might Nightshade not be effective on all AI art generators?

    -According to a comment on the air war subreddit, the effectiveness of Nightshade might be limited to models like Stable Diffusion that are based on CLIP. Other generators with different underlying technologies or that are not open source may not be affected in the same way.

  • What are the visual effects of using Glaze, as mentioned in the script?

    -The speaker mentions that using Glaze can lead to 'ugly artifacts' on the artwork, such as a green haze, which can significantly alter and degrade the appearance of the original art.

  • What is the sentiment of the artist community towards AI and technology, as expressed in the transcript?

    -The artist community appears to have mixed feelings. While they recognize the potential of AI technology, there's a strong desire for ethical use that respects artists' rights and contributions.

  • How do the 'AI bros' and 'eyebrows' groups differ in their views on AI in art?

    -The 'AI bros' seem to advocate for unrestricted technological advancement, whereas the 'eyebrows' group, possibly artists or ethical advocates, are more concerned with the implications of AI on creative rights and ethical standards.

  • What are the hopes of the speaker regarding the impact of Nightshade on AI art generation?

    -The speaker hopes that Nightshade will create a new discourse around AI art generation, ideally shifting the focus away from using AI to appropriate artists' work without permission.

  • Why does the speaker mention a preference for subscribing to certain Reddit communities?

    -The speaker encourages subscribing to artist-focused communities like 'artist hate' as a way to support and engage with content that aligns with artists' interests and concerns about AI art generation and ethical practices.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Artistic Concerns Over AI Image Generation

In this paragraph, the speaker, an artist, discusses the implications of a new AI tool called Nightshade, which is being developed by the same team behind Glaze of Chicago. The artist is concerned about the potential of Nightshade to 'poison the water hole' by confusing AI models, particularly those based on stable diffusion. The speaker notes that while stable diffusion is popular due to its privacy features, they are unsure about the effectiveness of Nightshade on other AI models. The artist also touches on the ethical considerations of AI-generated art, the potential for it to commandeer artists' work, and the backlash from professionals who feel threatened by this technology. The artist expresses a desire for a discourse that respects artists' rights while also acknowledging the potential for AI to assist in their work.

05:00

📢 Engaging with the Artist Community on Reddit

The speaker encourages their followers to subscribe to their Reddit account to support their growth and mentions another subreddit called 'artist hate' where artists discuss industry issues without the confrontation of 'eyebrows'. The artist then asks their audience for their opinions on Nightshade, questioning whether it will be a beneficial tool and if they would consider using it on their artwork. They express hope that any negative visual effects, such as a 'green haze', are just examples and not an inherent part of the Nightshade output. The artist concludes by wishing their audience a good day and inviting them to return for future updates.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Nightshade

Nightshade is introduced as a new project by the creators of Glaze, aimed at disrupting the functionality of AI models by confusing their recognition or processing capabilities. This tool is specifically designed to interfere with models like Stable Diffusion by altering the data they interpret, which could potentially shield artists' works from being used without permission. The person discusses Nightshade in the context of its potential to protect artistic integrity while expressing concerns about its aesthetic impact on artworks.

💡Glaze

Glaze is mentioned as an existing project related to Nightshade, also developed by the same team. It seems to serve a similar purpose of modifying images to prevent unauthorized use by AI models. The speaker has used Glaze on their work but notes that it introduces undesirable visual artifacts, which impacts the visual quality of the art. This critique highlights the practical challenges artists face when trying to protect their work with such technologies.

💡Stable Diffusion

Stable Diffusion is a type of AI model mentioned as widely used by the community for generating art because it allows for privacy and the creation of NSFW content. It is relevant in this discussion as the script implies that Nightshade would specifically target this type of model due to its accessibility and popularity among artists and tech users.

💡Artifacts

In the context of digital image processing, artifacts refer to any unwanted or unnatural alterations that appear in an image as a result of applying technology like Glaze. The speaker dislikes the 'ugly artifacts' introduced by Glaze, stating that they degrade the aesthetic quality of the art. This term underlines a significant drawback of using technology to protect digital artwork.

💡Clip models

Clip models are AI technologies used to understand or generate images based on textual descriptions. They are relevant here as the basis for how technologies like Stable Diffusion operate, which Nightshade is designed to counteract. The discussion in the video suggests that understanding the technical underpinnings of these models is crucial to assessing the efficacy of protection tools like Nightshade.

💡Ethical AI

The concept of Ethical AI involves developing and using AI technologies in a manner that respects human values and ethical principles. In the video, the speaker emphasizes the need for AI to be ethical, particularly in how it interacts with artists' rights and the originality of artworks. This ties back to the community's concern over AI tools potentially exploiting artists' works without proper acknowledgment or compensation.

💡Reverse engineering

Reverse engineering in this context refers to the process of deconstructing AI models like those used in Stable Diffusion to understand and potentially alter their function. The speaker mentions how technology is being reverse engineered in ways that might hinder progress for certain tech enthusiasts, pointing to a conflict between preserving artists' rights and advancing technological capabilities.

💡Luddite

A Luddite historically refers to someone opposed to industrialization or new technologies. In the video, accusations of being a Luddite are thrown around within the debate on AI's role in art, reflecting the tension between those embracing AI tools for creation and those who see them as a threat to traditional artistic practices.

💡AI Bros

AI Bros, as mentioned in the title, likely refers to enthusiasts or proponents of AI technology, particularly in contexts where AI intersects with creative fields like art. The speaker suggests that these individuals are frustrated by technologies like Nightshade, which could restrict their ability to innovate freely using AI.

💡Grift

Grift in the context of the script seems to refer to the perception that the initial wave of enthusiasm around technologies like NFTs and AI-generated art was more about making quick money than contributing to the art community. The speaker's use of the term highlights skepticism towards the motives behind certain tech-driven movements within artistic spaces.

Highlights

Nightshade is a new project by the creators of Glaze, aimed at 'poisoning the water hole' for AI art models.

The project is designed to confuse AI models by altering what they 'see' or process.

Nightshade is based on CLIP models, similar to Stable Diffusion, which is widely used due to its privacy features.

There are concerns about the effectiveness of Nightshade on AI generators that are not based on open-source code.

The artist community has mixed reactions, with some expressing hostility towards AI's impact on their work.

Professional artists are upset that AI models cannot be created or controlled by them.

The artist discusses the ethical use of technology in the context of art, suggesting it was not developed with artists in mind.

NFTs have faded from prominence, with AI art and its implications now taking center stage.

Some AI-generated works are being sold at prices comparable to those of hiring a real artist, raising questions about quality and value.

The artist hopes for a discourse that leads professionals to move on, allowing artists to reclaim their space.

The artist expresses a desire for Nightshade to prevent AI generators from misappropriating artwork.

There is a debate about whether those opposing AI's role in art are acting like Luddites, trying to halt technological progress.

The artist suggests that AI technology is parasitic, using artists' work for profit without consideration of ethical implications.

The artist recommends that followers subscribe to their Reddit for updates and to grow their audience.

The subreddit 'artist hate' is mentioned as a place to discuss issues artists face without confrontation.

The artist asks for opinions on Nightshade, questioning whether it will be adopted by the community.

Concerns are raised about Nightshade potentially making artwork appear 'ugly' with a green haze.

The artist expresses hope that the green haze is just an example and not a permanent artifact of using Nightshade.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now