Can ChatGPT trick Turnitin software? Can Turnitin detect AI generated work?

ecologicaltime
19 Apr 202306:10

TLDRThe video explores the effectiveness of Turnitin, a widely used plagiarism detection software, in identifying AI-generated content. The creator submits essays crafted by an AI, including topics like cybernetics, qualitative vs. quantitative research, and Carl Jung's psychology, to Turnitin. The software successfully flags the AI-generated content, with varying degrees of accuracy. In a final test, Turnitin identifies 62% of an interleaved text as AI-generated, missing some parts but overall performing well in distinguishing AI from human-written content.

Takeaways

  • 🔍 The video aims to test if Turnitin can detect AI-generated content.
  • 📝 The creator submitted various AI-generated essays on scholarly topics to Turnitin.
  • 📈 Turnitin provides a similarity report indicating the uniqueness of the content.
  • 🤖 The first essay, entirely AI-generated, was correctly identified by Turnitin as 100% AI-generated.
  • 🔍 Turnitin accurately detected AI content in essays on quantitative vs. qualitative research and Carl Jung's psychology.
  • 📊 The AI detection rate varied, with one essay on Carl Jung's psychology only scoring 81% AI-generated.
  • 📚 The creator also tested Turnitin's ability to differentiate between AI-generated and personal content.
  • 📝 In the mixed content test, Turnitin scored 62% AI-generated, but missed some sections.
  • 🔧 Turnitin's inconsistency was noted, as it correctly identified AI content in earlier tests but missed some in later ones.
  • 🧠 The video suggests that Turnitin is generally effective but not foolproof in detecting AI-generated content.
  • 📹 More tests and videos on this topic are planned for future uploads.

Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the video?

    -The main purpose of the video is to test whether Turnitin, a popular plagiarism detection software, can identify AI-generated content.

  • How did the user attempt to deceive Turnitin?

    -The user attempted to deceive Turnitin by submitting essays generated by an AI, specifically Chat GPT, to see if the software could detect their AI origin.

  • What types of essays were submitted to Turnitin?

    -The essays submitted included topics on cybernetics, second-order cybernetics, the difference between qualitative and quantitative research, Carl Jung's psychology, Teachback in cybernetics, and solar panel manufacturing.

  • What was the AI value for the first essay on cybernetics?

    -The AI value for the first essay on cybernetics was 100%, indicating that Turnitin correctly identified the entire essay as AI-generated.

  • How accurate was Turnitin in detecting AI-generated content in the essay on Carl Jung's psychology?

    -Turnitin was only able to identify 81% of the essay on Carl Jung's psychology as AI-generated, missing some parts of the essay.

  • What was the result when the user interleaved AI-generated content with their own work?

    -Turnitin scored 62% as being AI-generated, correctly identifying most of the AI content but missing some sections that were actually AI-written.

  • How does Turnitin provide its results?

    -Turnitin provides a similarity report that shows how similar the content is to other sources on the internet and also indicates if the content was generated by AI.

  • What was the user's conclusion about Turnitin's ability to detect AI-generated content?

    -The user concluded that Turnitin did a pretty good job in detecting AI-generated content, although it missed some sections in certain essays.

  • How did the user differentiate between AI-generated and their own content in the interleaved test?

    -The user differentiated between AI-generated and their own content by using a different font for their own text in the interleaved test.

  • What was the similarity score for the final essay on solar panel manufacturing?

    -The similarity score for the final essay on solar panel manufacturing was very low, but Turnitin still scored it as 100% AI-generated.

Outlines

00:00

🔍 Testing Turnitin's AI Detection Capabilities

The video script describes an experiment to test Turnitin's ability to detect AI-generated content. The creator submits essays written by AI, specifically by Chechi PT, on various scholarly topics to Turnitin, a plagiarism detection software used by educational institutions. The essays include topics like cybernetics, second-order cybernetics, qualitative vs. quantitative research, Carl Jung's psychology, and solar panel manufacturing. The Turnitin similarity report is used to determine the percentage of AI-generated content. The results show varying degrees of detection, with some essays being identified as 100% AI-generated and others, like the one on Carl Jung's psychology, being identified as only 81% AI-generated. The creator also tests Turnitin's ability to differentiate between AI-generated content and their own writing by interleaving both, resulting in a 62% AI detection score.

05:01

📝 Analyzing Turnitin's AI Detection Accuracy

The summary of the second paragraph discusses the detailed results of the Turnitin test. It highlights the accuracy of Turnitin in identifying AI-generated content, with some essays being correctly identified as entirely AI-written, while others, like the one on Carl Jung's psychology, were not fully detected. The creator notes that Turnitin missed some sections of the AI-generated content but overall performed well. The video concludes with the creator's satisfaction with Turnitin's performance and a promise to share more test results in future videos.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Turnitin

Turnitin is a plagiarism detection software used by educational institutions to check the originality of student submissions. It compares the content against a vast database of academic papers, articles, and web content to identify similarities. In the video, the user tests Turnitin's ability to detect AI-generated content, specifically essays created by an AI named Chat GPT.

💡Plagiarism

Plagiarism refers to the act of using someone else's work, ideas, or words without giving proper credit or permission. It is considered an academic dishonesty and is generally prohibited in educational settings. The video explores Turnitin's effectiveness in detecting plagiarism, particularly in the context of AI-generated content.

💡AI-Generated Content

AI-generated content is material created by artificial intelligence, such as essays, articles, or other written works. In the context of the video, the user is interested in whether Turnitin can identify essays that were entirely composed by an AI, specifically Chat GPT, as opposed to human-written content.

💡Cybernetics

Cybernetics is a multidisciplinary field that deals with the study of systems and communication, particularly how control and communication can be applied to the understanding of complex systems. In the video, the user asks Chat GPT to write an essay on cybernetics, which is then submitted to Turnitin to test the software's detection capabilities.

💡Second Order Cybernetics

Second order cybernetics is a branch of cybernetics that focuses on the observer's role in the creation of knowledge and the understanding that systems are self-organizing and self-referential. The video script mentions a request for an essay on this topic to challenge Turnitin's ability to discern AI-generated content from original work.

💡Qualitative vs Quantitative Research

Qualitative and quantitative research are two distinct approaches to gathering and analyzing data. Qualitative research focuses on understanding the quality and meaning of social phenomena, while quantitative research deals with quantifying variables and statistical analysis. The user's request for an essay on the differences between these two research methods is used to test Turnitin's detection capabilities.

💡Carl Jung Psychology

Carl Jung was a Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who founded analytical psychology. His theories include the concept of the collective unconscious and the archetypes. In the video, an essay on Carl Jung's psychology is generated by Chat GPT and submitted to Turnitin to evaluate the software's ability to identify AI-generated content.

💡Similarity Report

A similarity report is a document provided by Turnitin that shows the percentage of a student's work that matches other sources in the Turnitin database. It helps educators determine if a submission contains plagiarized content. The video discusses the similarity reports for various AI-generated essays to assess Turnitin's accuracy in detecting AI content.

💡Interleaving

Interleaving in the context of the video refers to the practice of mixing AI-generated content with human-written content. The user interleaves essays produced by Chat GPT with their own writing to test Turnitin's ability to differentiate between the two. This method is used to challenge the software's detection algorithms.

💡AI Value

In the context of Turnitin, the AI value is a score that indicates the percentage of a document that is determined to be generated by artificial intelligence. The video script mentions various AI values for different essays, highlighting Turnitin's performance in identifying AI-generated content.

💡Solar Panel Manufacturing

Solar panel manufacturing is the process of creating photovoltaic solar panels, which convert sunlight into electricity. The video includes an essay on this topic as part of the test to see if Turnitin can accurately identify AI-generated content in a specialized subject area.

Highlights

The video aims to test if Turnitin can detect AI-generated work.

Essays were composed by Chat GPT and submitted to Turnitin.

Turnitin provides a similarity report to identify plagiarized content.

Chat GPT's essays were written on specific scholarly topics.

The first essay on cybernetics was 100% AI-generated and detected by Turnitin.

The second essay on quantitative vs. qualitative research was also 100% AI-generated and correctly identified by Turnitin.

The third essay on Carl Jung's psychology was 81% AI-generated, but Turnitin only detected AI generation for part of it.

The fourth essay on Teach back in cybernetics was 100% AI-generated and accurately identified by Turnitin.

The fifth essay on solar panel manufacturing was 100% AI-generated and correctly identified by Turnitin.

The experiment also included interleaving AI-generated content with the user's own work.

Turnitin scored 62% AI generation for the interleaved content, but missed some sections.

Turnitin's ability to detect AI-generated content is generally good but not perfect.

The video demonstrates the potential and limitations of Turnitin in detecting AI-generated academic work.

The user plans to post more videos on similar tests in the future.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now