Don’t Use ChatGPT! Use This Instead

The Nerdy Novelist
5 Apr 202414:04

TLDRThe video discusses the limitations of Chat GPT for writing, highlighting issues with its style and creativity. It suggests alternatives such as open source models on Open Router, Claude 3 for natural-sounding prose, and Novel Crafter for tailored writing experiences, especially beneficial for fiction writers. The speaker, an experienced author, compares outputs and recommends experimenting with different tools for improved results.

Takeaways

  • 🌟 Chat GPT is recognized as a popular AI writing tool, but there are concerns about its efficacy in producing quality writing.
  • 📝 The speaker acknowledges the role of Chat GPT in their channel's inception but critiques its writing abilities.
  • ✍️ Despite specific style prompts, Chat GPT's output often remains overly flowery and melodramatic, not aligning with skilled writing standards.
  • 🚀 Alternative AI writing tools like Claude and Gemini are suggested for better creative ideation and more natural prose.
  • 🎨 For image generation, tools like Mid Journey and Leonardo offer superior capabilities compared to Dolly 3.
  • 🔍 Open router provides a platform to experiment with various open source models, offering a pay-as-you-go model.
  • 📚 Mr. Large, an open source model, is highlighted for its quality and flexibility in content creation with less censorship.
  • 🎉 Claude 3 is praised for its natural sounding prose and responsiveness to detailed prompts, excelling in matching user writing styles.
  • 💡 Gemini is noted for its brainstorming capabilities, though its writing quality may not surpass Chat GPT significantly.
  • 🖋️ Novel Crafter is introduced as a tool that caters to fiction and non-fiction writers, integrating various AI models for a tailored writing experience.
  • 📈 The video script emphasizes the importance of exploring different AI writing tools to find the best fit for one's writing needs and style.

Q & A

  • What is the main argument of the speaker against using Chat GPT for writing?

    -The speaker argues that Chat GPT is not very good at writing, producing overly flowery and melodramatic prose that often does not match the desired style or improve with specific prompts.

  • What are some redeeming qualities of Chat GPT mentioned in the script?

    -Chat GPT is good at following directions for specific tasks, summarization, and performing simple tasks that an AI tool might be needed for.

  • How does the speaker describe the writing style of Chat GPT?

    -The speaker describes Chat GPT's writing style as over the top, using too much description and adjectives, resulting in a purple prose that is not typical of a novel.

  • What are some alternatives to Chat GPT for creative ideation?

    -The alternatives mentioned are Claude and Gemini, which are better at the creative ideation phase, helping to get unstuck and providing more unique and outside-the-box ideas.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on using Chat GPT for image generation with Dolly 3?

    -While Dolly 3 was impressive at its release, the speaker believes that it has been surpassed by other image generating tools like Mid Journey, Leonard, and Idiogram.

  • How does the speaker describe the open source models available on Open Router?

    -The speaker describes the open source models on Open Router as extremely cheap and a good option for writing content that requires a more edgy or uncensored approach.

  • What makes Claude 3 stand out among other AI writing tools according to the speaker?

    -Claude 3 stands out for its natural sounding prose, responsiveness to style prompts, and ability to match the user's writing style with minimal editing required.

  • What is the main advantage of Novel Crafter over other AI writing tools?

    -Novel Crafter's main advantage is its ability to tailor the writing experience for fiction and non-fiction writers by incorporating detailed character information and matching the author's style more effectively.

  • How does the speaker evaluate the performance of Chat GPT compared to other AI writing tools?

    -The speaker evaluates Chat GPT as lacking in creativity and style flexibility compared to other tools like Claude 3, Gemini, and open source models found on Open Router.

  • What is the speaker's recommendation for writers who are looking for an AI writing tool?

    -The speaker recommends avoiding Chat GPT and instead exploring alternatives like Claude 3, Gemini, and Novel Crafter, depending on the specific needs of the writer.

  • What are the key factors to consider when choosing an AI writing tool according to the script?

    -Key factors to consider include the naturalness of the prose, responsiveness to style prompts, creativity in ideation, ability to match the author's writing style, and the level of censorship or edginess required for the content.

Outlines

00:00

🚫 Limitations of Chat GPT for Writing

The paragraph discusses the inadequacy of Chat GPT for writing tasks, despite its popularity among AI writing tools. The speaker, a seasoned writer with 14 books, criticizes the tool for producing overly flowery and melodramatic prose that doesn't match the style of skilled writers. The speaker also highlights that even with specific style prompts, the output remains largely unchanged and lacks the quality expected in professional writing. The paragraph also touches on the potential for better alternatives and the limitations of Chat GPT in creative ideation.

05:00

🌟 Better Alternatives for Creative Ideation

This paragraph explores alternative AI tools that excel in creative ideation, which Chat GPT struggles with. The speaker recommends Claude and Gemini for generating ideas and overcoming writer's block. It is noted that while Chat GPT can be used for brainstorming, other tools provide more innovative and out-of-the-box ideas. The paragraph also discusses the capabilities of Dolly 3 for image generation and its subsequent competitors, Mid Journey and Leonardo, which offer better image generation services.

10:01

📚 Tailored Writing Tools for Fiction and Non-Fiction

The speaker introduces specialized tools for writers of fiction and non-fiction, including open source models available on Open Router and the highly responsive Claude 3 models. The paragraph emphasizes the natural and human-like prose generated by Claude 3 and its ability to adapt to a writer's style with minimal editing. Additionally, the speaker discusses Novel Crafter, a tool designed for fiction writers that utilizes AI models to enhance character development and scene creation, offering a more tailored and efficient writing experience.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Chat GPT

Chat GPT is an AI writing tool developed by OpenAI, known for its ability to generate human-like text based on given prompts. In the context of the video, it is mentioned as a starting point for the creator's journey but criticized for its limitations in writing quality and creative ideation.

💡Writing Quality

Writing quality refers to the overall effectiveness, readability, and stylistic appeal of the text produced. The video emphasizes that despite Chat GPT's popularity, its writing quality is often not up to the mark, especially when it comes to adhering to specific styles or producing creative content.

💡Creative Ideation

Creative ideation is the process of generating new ideas or concepts, which is crucial in writing for both fiction and non-fiction. The video argues that Chat GPT falls short in this aspect, often providing generic answers that lack originality and out-of-the-box thinking.

💡Alternative AI Tools

Alternative AI tools refer to other AI-based writing platforms or models that can be used as substitutes for Chat GPT. The video discusses several alternatives that offer better performance in terms of writing quality and creative ideation.

💡Open Router

Open Router is a platform that hosts various AI models, including open-source ones, allowing users to experiment with different models for their writing needs. It is highlighted as a cost-effective and flexible option for writers seeking alternatives to Chat GPT.

💡Claude 3

Claude 3 is an AI model known for its ability to produce natural-sounding, human-like prose and is particularly praised for its responsiveness to style prompts and its capability to match a writer's unique style.

💡Gemini

Gemini is another AI tool mentioned in the video, which, while not as strong as Claude 3 in terms of writing quality, is noted for its effectiveness in brainstorming and idea generation.

💡Novel Crafter

Novel Crafter is a writing tool designed to cater specifically to fiction and non-fiction writers by integrating various AI models and providing features that help tailor the writing process to the writer's needs, such as character information and scene beats.

💡Style Prompts

Style prompts are specific instructions given to an AI tool to influence the tone, voice, or stylistic elements of the generated text. The video discusses the effectiveness of style prompts in improving the output of certain AI models, particularly Claude 3.

💡Censorship

Censorship in the context of AI writing tools refers to the limitations placed on the content that the AI can generate, often to adhere to community guidelines or legal restrictions. The video mentions the use of certain models that allow for more edgy content when censorship is less stringent.

💡Image Generating Tools

Image generating tools are AI-based services that create visual content based on textual descriptions. While Chat GPT can be used with Dolly 3 for image generation, the video mentions that other tools like Mid Journey and Leonardo have surpassed it in quality.

Highlights

Chat GPT is not recommended for writing tasks despite being the most well-known AI writing tool.

The speaker acknowledges the importance of Chat GPT in the inception of their channel and the potential for future models from Open AI to be promising.

Chat GPT excels at following directions and performing simple tasks such as summarization.

The quality of writing produced by Chat GPT is often overly flowery and melodramatic, not aligning with the desired style.

Skilled writers can easily identify text written by AI like Chat GPT due to its distinctive prose.

Chat GPT lacks creativity in ideation and tends to provide generic answers.

Alternative AI writing tools like Claude and Gemini offer better performance in creative ideation.

Dolly 3, an image generating tool, has been surpassed by other services like Mid Journey, Leonard, and Idiogram.

Open router provides a platform to test various open source AI models without censorship.

Mr. Large, an open source model, is comparable to Chat GPT in quality but allows for more flexibility.

Claude 3 is recommended for its natural sounding prose and responsiveness to style prompts.

Gemini is good for brainstorming but not as strong in writing compared to Claude 3.

Novel Crafter is a tool tailored for fiction writers, utilizing various AI models to enhance the writing experience.

Novel Crafter allows writers to input detailed character information to produce unique dialogue and scenes.

The tool can adapt to a writer's style by analyzing their previous work, making it highly customizable.

Novel Crafter is also suitable for non-fiction writers, though the process differs slightly.

Create Stunning AI Art Instantly

No login. No cost. Just incredible AI images !

Create Stunning AI Art InstantlyGenerate Now