I Just Experienced Tesla's FSD v12, And It's
TLDRThe script describes a first-hand experience with V12, an advanced driving software, in comparison to its predecessor, V11. The user, Farad, shares his observations as the software navigates through various scenarios, including parking lots, three-way stops, and U-turns in Georgetown, Texas. He notes improvements in smoothness, human-like behavior, and confidence-inspiring actions, such as handling pedestrians and adapting to traffic conditions. However, he also points out instances where V12 exhibits overly aggressive behavior, suggesting a need for refinement. The overall impression is that V12 is a significant step forward, but still requires some adjustments to ensure optimal safety and user trust.
Takeaways
- 🚗 The user is experiencing V12 for the first time and finds it smoother and more human-like compared to V11.
- 📍 The V12 software navigates out of a parking lot and handles a three-way stop with ease.
- 🛣️ The user notes that V12 confidently enters traffic from a parking lot, unlike V11 which was less reliable.
- 🚦 V12 makes a U-turn in Texas, demonstrating its adaptability to local driving habits.
- 🚨 The user appreciates V12's cautious approach around pedestrians, providing a sense of safety.
- 📈 V12's acceleration and braking are smoother, giving passengers a higher level of confidence.
- 🚙 The user observes that V12 sometimes makes overly aggressive decisions, potentially compromising safety.
- 🅿️ V12's parking capabilities are impressive, with the car finding and using parking spots effectively.
- 🔄 The user notes that V12 seems to be trying to resolve all driving scenarios at once, rather than focusing on specific stacks.
- 🚨 There are instances where V12 behaves too aggressively, such as entering intersections when it shouldn't.
- 🔍 The user suggests that while V12 has improved comfort, it may need further refinement to maintain the same level of safety as V11.
Q & A
What is the main focus of the discussion in the transcript?
-The main focus of the discussion is the comparison between the V12 and V11 versions of a driving software, specifically in terms of its performance in various driving scenarios.
How does the speaker describe their first experience with V12?
-The speaker describes their first experience with V12 as extremely positive, noting its smooth and human-like behavior, especially in comparison to V11.
What specific scenario did the speaker observe to compare V12 and V11?
-The speaker observed a scenario where the car needed to navigate out of a parking lot and handle a three-way stop, which they found V12 handled smoothly and confidently.
What is the speaker's opinion on V12's behavior around pedestrians?
-The speaker appreciates that V12 seems to respect pedestrians by giving them a wide berth and not freaking out around them, which they find reassuring.
How does the speaker feel about the acceleration and braking of V12?
-The speaker feels that V12's acceleration and braking are smooth and very human-like, providing a sense of confidence to the passengers.
What is the speaker's perspective on the adoption of autonomous driving software by the public?
-The speaker believes that for widespread adoption, the public needs to feel confident that the car is acting as expected and that subtle cues from the car's behavior are crucial for this trust.
What issue did the speaker identify with V12 during the test drive?
-The speaker identified that V12 can sometimes be too aggressive, attempting to enter intersections when it shouldn't, which could potentially lead to unsafe situations.
How does the speaker describe the car's behavior when it encounters a pedestrian?
-The speaker describes the car's behavior as natural and confidence-inspiring, noting that the car predictably and smoothly navigates through a pedestrian gap.
What is the speaker's overall assessment of V12's performance?
-The speaker is impressed with V12's performance, noting that it has already demonstrated capabilities not seen in V11 and feels more natural. However, they also point out that there are instances where V12 needs improvement, particularly in its aggressiveness.
What does the speaker suggest about Tesla's approach to developing V12?
-The speaker suggests that Tesla is trying to solve the entire driving equation with V12, rather than focusing on specific scenarios like parking lots, city driving, or highways.
Outlines
🚗 First Impressions of V12
The speaker discusses their initial experience with V12, noting the positive feedback from others and comparing it to V11. They observe the software's ability to navigate a parking lot, handle a three-way stop, and make a left turn. The speaker appreciates the smooth and human-like behavior of V12, especially in parking situations where V11 was less reliable. They also mention the car's confident entry into traffic and the reassurance it provides as a passenger.
🚦 V12's Interaction with Pedestrians
The speaker comments on V12's cautious approach towards pedestrians, which they see as a positive aspect for public adoption. They discuss the importance of the car's behavior in inspiring confidence in the driver and passengers. The speaker notes the smooth acceleration and braking of V12, which feels more natural and reassuring compared to V11. They also mention the car's ability to adapt its speed based on the surroundings, even without the Auto speed setting.
🛣️ V12's City Driving and Parking
The speaker describes V12's performance in city driving, including its ability to make U-turns and navigate through downtown Georgetown. They note the car's natural and confident behavior, such as accelerating and handling stop signs. The speaker also discusses the car's parking capabilities, including its ability to find a parking spot and park smoothly. They mention the car's aggressive behavior at times, which could be a point of improvement for the Tesla team.
🚨 Evaluating V12's Safety and Aggressiveness
The speaker evaluates V12's safety features, noting instances where the software was overly aggressive, such as attempting to enter an intersection when it wasn't safe. They compare this to V11's more cautious behavior, which they feel provided a higher level of safety. The speaker emphasizes the importance of the car's behavior in ensuring the comfort and trust of its passengers, suggesting that while V12 has improved in many ways, there is still room for improvement in terms of safety and confidence.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡V12
💡Parking Lot Navigation
💡U-Turn
💡Pedestrian Interaction
💡Acceleration
💡Braking
💡Adoption
💡Safety
💡Aggressiveness
💡Taxi Driver
💡Intersection Management
Highlights
Experience with V12 software and its smooth, human-like behavior.
Comparison of V12 with V11, noting improvements in navigation and handling complex scenarios.
Observation of V12's confident handling of a three-way stop and parking lot navigation.
V12's ability to transition lanes effectively and the user's satisfaction with its performance.
V12's parking capabilities and the user's positive reaction to its parking skills.
V12's cautious approach around pedestrians and the user's appreciation for this feature.
User's confidence in V12's driving decisions and the car's ability to reassure passengers.
V12's smooth acceleration and braking, providing a comfortable ride experience.
V12's adaptability to different driving conditions and its ability to adjust speed based on surroundings.
User's observation of V12's potential over-aggressiveness in certain situations.
V12's handling of U-turns and the user's positive feedback on its execution.
V12's approach to handling stop signs and its decision-making process.
User's anticipation of V12's parking behavior and the car's actual performance.
V12's interaction with pedestrians and its natural response to finding a pathway.
User's critique of V12's occasional aggressiveness and the need for refinement.
V12's handling of traffic and intersections, with the user noting its safety concerns.
